Tools › Mechanical Design › Vehicle Dynamics › Pinewood Derby Car


Pinewood Derby Car

Enter the weight, balance point and wheels of a gravity-powered wooden derby car and the track; get its finish time and speed and how far it beats a rival car at the line, with a drawing of your car. Every limit is a value you enter: follow the rules of your own race.

  • The gap at the finish against a rival car, in time, distance and car lengths

  • Finish time against where the car balances, with the zone where the front wheels get too light

  • Where the energy went: speed, wheel spin, axle friction, rolling resistance, air drag

  • One change at a time: weight back, lighter wheels, lubrication, lower body, full weight, a raised wheel

Pinewood Derby Car


Unit System: /

/

Your Car












Track





Rival Car








Wheels, Axles and Layout








Limits and What-If Changes






×

Pinewood Derby Car

Method: Why the Weight Goes at the Back, Wheel Inertia, Friction, Air Drag, Common Mistakes

What the tool does

It rolls a gravity-powered wooden derby car down a ramp, through a curve and along a level run, and gives its finish time and speed. It then races the car against a rival and against itself with one thing changed, so that you can see what each change is worth at the finish line.

The idea: the only fuel is the height the car loses

A derby car has no engine. All of its speed comes from the height that its center of mass (its balance point) loses between the start and the finish. Every car starts with its nose against the same start line, so a car whose balance point is further back has that point higher up the ramp, and it falls further. That is the whole reason builders put the weight at the back.

A derby car on a 25 degree ramp with its nose on the start line. A balance point 1.2 inches further back along the car sits 0.51 inch higher than a balance point in the middle.
The same car with its weight at the back or in the middle. On a 25° ramp, 1.2 in further back is 0.51 in more height to fall, about 1 % more energy on a 4 ft ramp.

The equations

The track is a straight ramp at the angle θ, a circular curve of radius R and a level run. H is the height of the start line above the level run and L the length of track from start line to finish line. The car has the weight W (mass m), its center of mass a distance d behind the nose and a height h above the track.

  • Drop of the center of mass: z = H + d sin θ − h (1 − cos θ). The middle term is the gain from weight at the back. The last term is small: a car tilted on the ramp carries a high center of mass a little lower, so a low center of mass falls slightly further.
  • The curve: there the center of mass runs on the smaller radius R − h, a slightly shorter path, so it moves at (R − h) / R of the speed of the wheels. This shortcut almost exactly cancels the extra drop of a low center of mass: by itself, the height of the balance point changes the finish time by well under a thousandth of a second. A low body helps because of air drag, not because of its low center of mass.
  • Speed if nothing were lost: v = √(2 g z), with g = 9.80665 m/s². It does not depend on the weight.
  • Spin of the wheels: a wheel of mass mw whose radius of gyration is k times its outer radius stores the energy ½ mw k² v² in spin, on top of its share of the forward motion. With n wheels turning, the car behaves as if its mass were m + n mw k², and the speed drops to v / √(1 + n mw k² / m). A solid disk has k = 0.71; a wheel with all its mass at the rim has k = 1.
  • Axle friction: the wheel bore slides on the axle with the friction coefficient μ. Because the axle is much smaller than the wheel, the drag felt at the track is only μ (daxle / dwheel) times the load on the axles. The axles carry the car without the wheels that roll on the track.
  • Rolling resistance: Crr times the force between wheels and track.
  • Force on the track: N = m g cos (slope), plus the centripetal force in the curve, where the track also has to turn the car.
  • Air drag: ½ ρ Cd A v², with ρ = 1.2 kg/m³ and A = body width × body height.
  • Motion: (m + n mw k²) dv/dt = (pull of gravity along the track) − (axle friction + rolling resistance) − (air drag). The tool steps this equation in time with the fourth-order Runge-Kutta method in steps of 1 ms, landing exactly on the two ends of the curve and on the finish line. The clock starts when the car is released and stops when its nose reaches the finish line.
  • Gap at the finish: the position of the slower car's nose at the instant the faster one finishes, read from its stored motion.
  • Front wheels: on level track the front wheels carry the share x / (wheelbase) of the weight, where x is the balance point measured forward from the rear axle. At x = 0 they carry nothing and lift.

What the results usually show

  • Moving the weight back helps, but only by the extra height: about 1 % of the energy for each inch or so on a typical ramp. It is free, which is why everyone does it.
  • Friction, air drag and wheel spin each take several percent of the energy, so polished and lubricated axles, a low body and light wheels are usually worth more than the last half inch of weight shift.
  • A heavier car is not faster in a vacuum. It wins because air drag and the spin of the wheels take a smaller share of a larger energy.
  • A front wheel raised off the track saves the energy of spinning it up. In this model it does nothing else.

What it assumes

  • The car runs straight and all wheels that touch the track roll without slipping.
  • The friction coefficient at the axles and the rolling resistance are constant, and the same for every wheel.
  • The car is short compared with the curve: its center of mass follows the track at the height h, the change of its speed at the two ends of the curve happens at once instead of over one wheelbase, and the energy of the body's own slow pitching rotation in the curve (roughly 0.2 % of the total, returned at the end of the curve) is left out.
  • Still air at 1.2 kg/m³, one drag coefficient for body and wheels together.
  • The start gate releases the car cleanly and the timer reads the nose.

When it misleads

  • As a prediction of the timer. The friction, drag and wheel values are illustrative, typed from memory, not measurements of any kit or product. Differences between two cars are far more trustworthy than either time.
  • When the car does not run straight. A wheel rubbing the body or the guide rail, a bent axle, a wobbling wheel or a bump at a track joint can cost more than every gain in the table. None of that is in the model.
  • With the weight very far back. The curve says faster all the way to the rear axle, but a car with a light front end wanders, bounces or jumps the rail. The shaded zone uses an entered rule of thumb (15 % of the weight on the front wheels by default), not a law of physics.
  • On tracks of another shape. A long S-shaped or fully curved ramp is not a straight ramp plus one arc. Enter the nearest equivalent and compare cars, not times.
  • Rules. Weight limits, wheel and axle modifications, raised wheels and lubricants are allowed in some races and not in others. Every limit here is a value you enter. Follow the rules of your own race.

Common mistakes

  • Thinking a heavier car falls faster. Without friction and air every car reaches the same speed. Weight helps only because the losses do not grow as fast as the energy.
  • Measuring the drop from the track surface instead of from the center of mass. Two cars on the same ramp fall different heights.
  • Forgetting the wheels. A rolling wheel has to be spun up as well as moved forward, so its mass counts roughly one and a half times.
  • Applying the friction coefficient at the wheel rim. It acts at the axle, so it is reduced by the ratio of axle diameter to wheel diameter (about 1 to 14 here).
  • Using sliding friction of the wheels on the track. The wheels roll: there is no sliding at the tread, only the much smaller rolling resistance.
  • Adding up separate gains. Each gain depends on the others, so the total is not their sum.
  • Expecting a low center of mass to be faster by itself. It gains a little height on the ramp and loses the same again in the curve.
  • Putting the balance point behind the rear axle. The front wheels lift and the car leaves the rail.
  • Comparing times from different tracks. Compare gaps on the same track.

Checks behind this page

There is no published government example for this problem, so the library is checked against mathematics only. The finish time and speed of 40 seeded cars on five tracks and of the "Try this" cars agree with two separate computations written in Python: a high-accuracy time integration with scipy, and the energy equation solved along the track (it is linear in v²) with the time found by quadrature. Frictionless cars agree with the closed forms v = √(2 g z m / (m + n mw k²)), √(2 s / a) on the ramp and distance / speed on the level run. The energy account closes to rounding in every run. The unit conversions (inch, foot, ounce, mile per hour, standard gravity) are those of NIST Special Publication 811. The default wheel weight, wheel and axle diameters, friction coefficients, rolling resistance, drag coefficient and air density are illustrative values typed from memory.

References

Thompson, A., and Taylor, B. N. (2008). Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI). NIST Special Publication 811, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Coletta, V. P., and Evans, J. (2008). "Analysis of a Model Race Car." American Journal of Physics, Vol. 76, No. 10, pp. 903–907.

Meriam, J. L., Kraige, L. G., and Bolton, J. N. (2015). Engineering Mechanics: Dynamics, 8th ed. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.




References

Thompson, A., and Taylor, B. N. (2008). Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI). NIST Special Publication 811, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Coletta, V. P., and Evans, J. (2008). "Analysis of a Model Race Car." American Journal of Physics, Vol. 76, No. 10, pp. 903–907.

Meriam, J. L., Kraige, L. G., and Bolton, J. N. (2015). Engineering Mechanics: Dynamics, 8th ed. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.


DISCLAIMER: The methods and calculation on aNOWysis.com are provided as means to educate the reader. There is no warranty, expessed or implied, as to the relevance or accuracy of the methods or calculations. All calculations should be checked by a qualified analyst for appropriateness and accuracy. We will not be held liable for any damages, injuries or deaths caused by using methods or calculations from this site.