Tools › Structures › Stress and Strain › Failure Theories


Failure Theories

Enter the stress at a point and the strength of the material; get the factor of safety by each static failure theory (maximum shear stress, distortion energy and Coulomb-Mohr for a ductile material; maximum normal stress, Coulomb-Mohr and modified Mohr for a brittle one), with your stress state drawn on the failure envelopes. Static loading of a uniform material only: no fatigue, no cracks, no buckling, no stress concentration unless it is already in the entered stress.

  • Plane stress, principal stresses or all six components of a three-dimensional state

  • Each factor of safety as formula, numbers, answer; which theory is the cautious one and which fits tests

  • The envelope chart: load point, load line and where it crosses each envelope

Failure Theories


Unit System: /

1. Stress at the Point (tension positive)











2. Material Strength







×

Failure Theories

Method: the Theories, the Envelope Chart, What It Assumes, Common Mistakes

What the tool does

It compares the stress at one point of a part with the strength of the material and gives the factor of safety by each of the classical static failure theories. It also draws your stress state on the failure envelopes, so that you can see how far it is from each of them and why the theories disagree.

To find the principal stresses of a state and the stresses on a rotated element, use Mohr's Circle; this tool starts from the same state and answers "does it fail, by which theory, with what margin".

The idea: one test, many stress states

A tension test gives one number: the stress at which a bar pulled in one direction yields or breaks. A real part is pulled, pushed and sheared in several directions at once. A failure theory is a rule that says which combination of stresses does the same damage as the single stress of the test. Each rule draws a closed boundary, the failure envelope, in a chart whose axes are the principal stresses: states inside are safe, states on the boundary are at failure.

Chart of the two in-plane principal stresses with the Tresca hexagon inside the von Mises ellipse, both passing through the yield strength on each axis, and the load line of pure shear from the origin O through the stress state A to the hexagon at B, 0.5 of the yield strength, and the ellipse at C, 0.577 of the yield strength
The two yield envelopes of a ductile material in plane stress, and the load line of pure shear. The factor of safety is a ratio of two lengths along the load line.

If every stress grows in proportion, the state moves outward from the origin along a straight load line. The factor of safety n is the distance from the origin to the envelope along that line divided by the distance from the origin to the state: n = OB / OA. It is the number by which all the stresses can be multiplied before the theory predicts failure.

Principal stresses

Every theory here is written in the principal stresses, ordered σ1 ≥ σ2 ≥ σ3, tension positive.

  • Plane stress (σx, σy, τxy on a free surface): the in-plane principal stresses are σA, σB = (σx + σy) / 2 ± √(((σx − σy) / 2)² + τxy²), and the third is zero. The zero takes its place in the order: it may be the largest, the middle or the smallest of the three.
  • Three-dimensional state: the principal stresses are the roots of σ³ − I1 σ² + I2 σ − I3 = 0, where I1 = σx + σy + σz, I2 = σxσy + σyσz + σzσx − τxy² − τyz² − τzx² and I3 is the determinant of the stress matrix. The tool solves the cubic in closed form.

Ductile materials: yielding

Maximum shear stress (Tresca): n = Sy / (σ1 − σ3)

Yielding is slip, and slip is driven by shear. The largest shear stress at a point is (σ1 − σ3) / 2; in a tension test at yield it is Sy / 2. In plane stress the envelope is a hexagon.

Distortion energy (von Mises): σ′ = √(((σ1 − σ2)² + (σ2 − σ3)² + (σ3 − σ1)²) / 2),   n = Sy / σ′

Only the part of the strain energy that changes the shape of the material, not its volume, causes yielding. The von Mises stress σ′ is the tension-test stress with the same distortion energy. In plane stress, σ′ = √(σA² − σAσB + σB²) and the envelope is an ellipse through the corners of the hexagon.

The hexagon lies inside the ellipse, so the maximum-shear-stress theory never gives the higher factor of safety. The two agree for a single stress and for equal biaxial stress, and differ most in pure shear: yield at τ = 0.5 Sy by the first and τ = Sy / √3 = 0.577 Sy by the second. Yield tests on ductile metals fall nearer the ellipse.

Ductile Coulomb-Mohr (yield strengths Syt in tension and Syc in compression): σ1 / Syt − σ3 / Syc = 1 / n

When all three principal stresses are tensile the tool uses σ1 = Syt / n instead (the largest stress alone). With Syt = Syc the theory is the maximum-shear-stress theory.

Brittle materials: fracture

A brittle material breaks without yielding and is usually much stronger in compression (Suc, entered as a positive number) than in tension (Sut).

Maximum normal stress (Rankine): n = the smaller of Sut / σ1 (when σ1 is tensile) and Suc / |σ3| (when σ3 is compressive)

Brittle Coulomb-Mohr: σ1 / Sut − σ3 / Suc = 1 / n,   or σ1 = Sut / n when no principal stress is compressive

Modified Mohr: σ1 = Sut / n while |σ3| ≤ σ1; otherwise (Suc − Sut) σ1 / (Suc Sut) − σ3 / Suc = 1 / n

The three agree when no principal stress is compressive. They part where tension and compression act together (the fourth quadrant of the chart, which includes torsion): the maximum normal stress theory ignores the compression beside the tension and is the least cautious, Coulomb-Mohr is the most cautious, and modified Mohr lies between. The textbooks cited report that biaxial fracture tests of gray cast iron fall closest to the modified Mohr line, so the tool leads with it. The NASA manual cited suggests the maximum normal stress theory for brittle materials; it is the same as modified Mohr whenever the compressive principal stress is no larger than the tensile one.

A brittle part cracks across the largest tensile stress. In a shaft in torsion that stress acts at 45° to the axis, which is why a twisted stick of chalk or a cast iron shaft breaks along a 45° helix, while a ductile shaft shears straight across.

The chart for a three-dimensional state

With three nonzero principal stresses the envelopes are surfaces. The tool draws them in the plane of the largest and smallest principal stresses, σ1 and σ3, where the maximum shear stress, maximum normal stress and both Mohr theories do not depend on σ2 and each envelope is a line. The distortion-energy line is drawn for the entered position of σ2 between σ3 and σ1, which stays the same as the load is scaled.

What it assumes

  • Static loading applied once, and stresses that all grow in proportion.
  • A uniform, isotropic material with the entered strengths: the same in every direction.
  • The entered stress is the true stress at the point. A stress concentration counts only if it is already in that number.
  • Ductile theories predict the start of yielding, not rupture; brittle theories predict fracture.

When it misleads

  • Fatigue. A part that passes here with a large factor can still fail under repeated loading at a much lower stress.
  • Cracks and sharp notches. Failure from a crack is governed by fracture mechanics, not by these theories.
  • Compression on all three axes. No theory here predicts yielding under equal pressure from all sides, and the Mohr theories credit confinement. For three compressive principal stresses the tool continues the Mohr lines beyond the plane-stress diagrams of the textbooks: treat those results as estimates.
  • Tension on all three axes. The yield theories predict no yielding for equal triaxial tension, yet a real material then fractures. The tool does not check that.
  • Composites, wood and other directional materials need theories with a strength for each direction.
  • Buckling of a thin part in compression can come long before the material strength is reached.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting the zero principal stress. In plane stress with both in-plane principal stresses tensile, the largest shear stress is σA / 2 (out of the plane), not (σA − σB) / 2. A pressure vessel wall is the usual victim.
  • Using stress components instead of principal stresses in the maximum shear stress or Mohr formulas. Find the principal stresses first.
  • Comparing the shear stress with the tensile yield strength. In pure shear a ductile metal yields at 0.5 to 0.577 of Sy, not at Sy.
  • Entering the compressive strength with a minus sign. Strengths are positive magnitudes here; only stresses carry a sign.
  • Applying a yield theory to a brittle material (or the reverse). Cast iron in torsion fails by the tension at 45°, which the von Mises stress does not describe.
  • Dropping the factor 3 on the shear term. For a normal stress σ with a shear stress τ, σ′ = √(σ² + 3τ²), while the maximum-shear-stress form is √(σ² + 4τ²).
  • Reading the factor of safety as a margin on one load. It scales every stress together. If only one load grows, the state moves along a different line.

Where the numbers were checked

The statements of the maximum normal stress, maximum shearing stress and distortion-energy theories, and the yield condition (σ1 − σ2)² + (σ2 − σ3)² + (σ1 − σ3)² = 2 Sy², were read in Section A1.4 of the NASA Astronautic Structures Manual, and its interaction equations for a normal stress with a shear stress (Section A3.2.1) are reproduced by the tool. The Coulomb-Mohr and modified Mohr expressions are the textbook forms, cited but not reproduced from an open document. Every factor of safety, the three-dimensional principal stresses and the points where the load line meets each envelope were checked against an independent calculation. The default strengths and the "Try this" cases are illustrative values, not data for a particular material.




References

National Aeronautics and Space Administration (1975). Astronautic Structures Manual, Volume I. NASA Technical Memorandum X-73305, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL.

Budynas, R. G., and Nisbett, J. K. (2015). Shigley's Mechanical Engineering Design, 10th ed. McGraw-Hill Education, New York.

Dowling, N. E. (2013). Mechanical Behavior of Materials, 4th ed. Pearson, Boston.

Boresi, A. P., and Schmidt, R. J. (2003). Advanced Mechanics of Materials, 6th ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.

von Mises, R. (1913). "Mechanik der festen Körper im plastisch-deformablen Zustand." Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse, pp. 582–592.

Tresca, H. (1864). "Mémoire sur l'écoulement des corps solides soumis à de fortes pressions." Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences, Vol. 59, pp. 754–758.


DISCLAIMER: The methods and calculation on aNOWysis.com are provided as means to educate the reader. There is no warranty, expessed or implied, as to the relevance or accuracy of the methods or calculations. All calculations should be checked by a qualified analyst for appropriateness and accuracy. We will not be held liable for any damages, injuries or deaths caused by using methods or calculations from this site.