Tools › Structures › Stress and Strain › Failure Theories › Example
Shaft in pure torsion: yield at 0.5 or 0.577 of the yield strength (Tresca against von Mises)
| Tool | Failure Theories |
| Source | Original case. Theories as stated in National Aeronautics and Space Administration (1975). Astronautic Structures Manual, Volume I. NASA Technical Memorandum X-73305, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL. Section A1.4, pp. 34–35. |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
The surface of a shaft in pure torsion carries a shear stress of 100 MPa and no normal stress. The material is ductile with a yield strength of 250 MPa (illustrative). Find the factor of safety against yielding by the maximum-shear-stress and distortion-energy theories and say why they differ.
Inputs to Enter
- Plane stress: σ_x = 0, σ_y = 0, τ_xy = 100 MPa
- Ductile material, yield strength S_y = 250 MPa (illustrative)
Answers
- Principal stresses σ_1 = 100 MPa, σ_2 = 0, σ_3 = −100 MPa (pure shear is equal tension and compression at 45°)
- Maximum shear stress (Tresca): σ_1 − σ_3 = 200 MPa, n = 250 / 200 = 1.25
- Distortion energy (von Mises): σ′ = √3 · 100 = 173.2 MPa, n = 250 / 173.2 = 1.44
- The load line meets the hexagon at (125, −125) MPa and the ellipse at (144.3, −144.3) MPa: yield at τ = 0.5 S_y against 0.577 S_y, the largest gap between the two theories
Notes
The tool opens on this case; press Submit, or open it in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/stress-strain/failure-theories/?try=pure-torsion. Numbers checked in test_failure_theories.php against closed forms and an independent numpy calculation.
More Examples for This Tool
- Thin pressure vessel wall: the zero principal stress that decides the maximum shear stress
- Brittle material in tension and compression: maximum normal stress, Coulomb-Mohr and modified Mohr compared
- Six stress components: principal stresses from the characteristic cubic and the yield factors of safety