Tools › Structures › Joints › Bonded Patch Repair


Bonded Patch Repair

A bonded composite or metal patch over a cracked or thinned metal skin by the Rose model. Stage I treats the patch and the skin under it as a stiffer elliptical inclusion: the load the reinforcement attracts, the stress left in the skin under the patch and at the patch end, the stress in the patch, the load-transfer length of the bond and the residual stress that cooling from the cure temperature leaves in the skin. Stage II puts the crack under the patch: the patch bridges it, so the stress intensity factor cannot exceed the limit K∞ = σ0 √(π Λ) however long the crack grows, and Rose's interpolation gives K for the entered crack length. The adhesive shear strain at the crack and at the patch end is found with an elastic-perfectly plastic adhesive, in closed form and by solving the overlap between the crack and the patch end. Margins of safety follow for the patch, the adhesive and the skin, at ultimate load for strength and at limit load for yield, and the design is compared with published guidance on stiffness ratio, overlap length and patch cover. The default is an illustrative five-ply boron-epoxy patch on 0.063 in 2024-T3 skin with a 1 in crack.

  • Stage I: load attraction of an elliptical patch by the inclusion analogy (Rose), skin stress under the patch and at the patch end, patch stress, load-transfer length 1/β

  • Stage II: crack-bridging limit K∞ = σ0 √(π Λ), Rose's interpolation for the entered crack, K with and without the patch and the reduction ratio, chart of K against crack length

  • Adhesive shear strain at the crack and at the patch end, elastic and elastic-plastic (SAND2005-3195 Appendix C); the overlap is also solved as a finite bonded joint (Hart-Smith)

  • Thermal residual stress from cure: ΔT, the two expansion coefficients and the effective coefficient αp (1 + ν) / 2 of a locally heated skin; by SAND2005-3195 eqs C-6 and C-8 (default) or as a bonded strip

  • Margins: patch tension and adhesive strain at ultimate, skin yield at limit × FSyld; stiffness ratio 1.0 to 1.2, overlap, cover beyond the crack tip and fatigue strain checks, each limit editable

Bonded Patch


Unit System: /

/

Repair and Load






Skin







Patch (elliptical; properties in the load direction)









Adhesive (shear stress-strain curve idealized as elastic-perfectly plastic)





Cure and Temperature






Load Level and Factors




Guidance Limits (editable)







×

Bonded Patch Repair Method

Bonded Patch Repair: Load Attraction, Crack Bridging, Adhesive Strain and Thermal Residual Stress

The repair and the question

A thin patch, usually a unidirectional boron-epoxy or carbon-epoxy laminate but sometimes a metal or fiber-metal sheet, is bonded over a crack or a corroded area of a metal skin. Unlike a riveted doubler it adds no holes and transfers load over its whole area. Four questions decide whether the repair works: how much the patch lowers the stress intensity factor of the crack, whether the patch and the adhesive can carry the load the crack no longer carries, how much extra load the stiffened area draws into the skin at the patch end, and what stress the cure cycle leaves behind. The tool answers them with the two-stage model of L. R. F. Rose, in the forms printed in public U.S. reports.

The load acts along y. The crack, of half length a, lies across the load under the center of the patch. The patch is an ellipse with half width A along the crack and half length B along the load. Subscript p is the skin (plate), r the patch (reinforcement), a the adhesive.

Stage I: the patch as a stiffer inclusion

Without the crack, and with a bond that is stiff compared with the patch dimensions, the patch and the skin under it behave as one elliptical region whose stiffness is (1 + S) times that of the skin, S = Er tr / (Ep tp). The stress in an elliptical inclusion is uniform, and Rose's closed form for the skin stress under the patch is σ0 = φ f with

φ = [4 + 2 B/A + 2 A/B + S (3 + ν + 2 B/A) + Σ S (1 − ν − 2 ν B/A)] / [3 (1 + S)² + 2 (1 + S)(B/A + A/B + ν S) + 1 − ν² S²],

where f is the remote stress along the load, Σ the ratio of the remote stress parallel to the crack to f, and ν Poisson's ratio (the same for skin and patch). Two limits show what the formula does. A patch that spans the whole width (A much larger than B) shares load as a strip: φ = 1 / (1 + S). A long narrow patch along the load (B much larger than A) must stretch with the skin beside it: φ = 1, and the reinforced strip carries (1 + S) times the remote load. A real patch lies between: it relieves the skin under it but attracts load, and the skin just outside the patch end carries the whole load of the region, ΩL f with ΩL = φ (1 + S). That stress is where a new crack would start, so it is checked against the skin strength and yield.

The patch stress away from the crack is φ f Er / Ep. Over the crack the skin carries nothing and the patch takes the whole load of the region: ΩL f tp / tr.

Load transfer and adhesive strain

Load passes between skin and patch by shear in the adhesive over a short length at the patch end and beside the crack. With the adhesive as a shear spring and skin and patch as bars, the shear stress decays as exp(−β y), with β² = (Ga / ta)(1 / (Ep tp) + 1 / (Er tr)); 1 / β is the load-transfer length, a few millimeters for thin skins and film adhesives. The inclusion picture holds when the patch is many transfer lengths long and wide.

At the end of a long overlap the elastic shear stress is τe = (Ga / (ta β)) × (difference in strain of the two adherends at that end). At the crack this is β tp σ0; at the patch end it is (Ga / (ta β)) × (skin stress at the patch end) / Ep, less the thermal mismatch strain εT in the bonded-strip model. With an elastic-perfectly plastic adhesive (plateau τp) the strain at the end is γ = τe / Ga while τe ≤ τp and γ = (τp / (2 Ga))(1 + (τe / τp)²) beyond. The allowable is the elastic limit plus the plastic strain capacity, τp / Ga + γp.

The tool also solves the bond between the patch end and the crack as a joint of finite length B with the elastic-plastic shear-lag solution of Hart-Smith (the library of the Adhesive Bonded Joint tool), and uses those end strains for the margins. For a long overlap they equal the closed forms; for a short one they are larger, and when the whole length would be plastic the tool reports that the overlap cannot transfer the load. A tapered patch end is treated by the long-overlap formula with the thickness of the first step, which lowers the end strain; the steps are assumed long enough to act as long overlaps.

Thermal residual stress

The patch is cured hot. On cooling, an aluminum skin contracts more than a boron or carbon patch, which leaves the skin under the patch in tension and the patch in compression. The mismatch strain is εT = (αp,eff − αr) ΔTcure + (αp − αr) ΔTservice. During cure only the repair area is hot and the cold structure around it restrains its expansion, so the skin behaves as if its expansion coefficient were lower: the effective value αp (1 + ν) / 2 is the one printed in the Sandia guidelines; a coupon heated throughout expands freely (αp). A change of service temperature cools everything together and takes the full coefficient.

Two models turn εT into stress; the choice is in Advanced mode. Neither result is multiplied by the factor of safety.

Guideline model (default; SAND2005-3195 Appendix C). Eq. C-6 adds the thermal term to the skin stress at the patch end as if it were a remote stress: σ** = ΩL f + Ep εT. Eq. C-8 gives the skin under the patch its stiffness share of that, σ0 = σ** / (1 + S), and eq. C-17 gives the patch over the crack σ** tp / tr. The bond sees the thermal term as added load at both ends, so nothing relieves the adhesive at the patch end. This is the more severe model for the skin at the patch end, the patch and the adhesive at the patch end.

Bonded strip. Skin and patch have equal strain and no net force: the skin under the patch keeps Ep εT S / (1 + S) in tension, the patch is in compression, and the skin outside the patch has no thermal stress. The mismatch adds to the adhesive strain at the crack and relieves it at the patch end. The two models give the same stress under the patch at S = 1; for a patch stiffer than the skin (S above 1) the strip leaves more stress under the patch, hence a slightly higher K and adhesive strain at the crack, while the guideline model is the more severe everywhere else.

Stage II: the crack under the patch

When the crack is opened under the patch, the load it carried goes into the patch through the adhesive beside the crack faces. Each face moves by u = σ0 tp β ta / Ga, however long the crack is. The energy released per unit of crack growth therefore reaches a ceiling, and with it the stress intensity factor:

K∞ = σ0 √(π Λ), π Λ = Ep tp β ta / Ga = (1 + 1/S) / β.

When the adhesive at the crack yields (P = σ0 β tp / τp above 1) the faces open further and K∞² = (Ep ta / Ga)[σ0 τp (1 + P²) − τp² (1 + 2 P³) / (3 β tp)], which is the complementary energy of the nonlinear bridging spring. A crack much shorter than Λ does not feel the patch beyond the reduced stress: K = σ0 √(π a). Rose's interpolation joins the two limits:

Kr = σ0 √(π a Λ / (a + Λ)).

The tool reports Kr, K∞, the unpatched value f √(π a) for a wide skin and their ratio, at limit load, and plots K against crack length. K∞ is an upper bound for a crack under the patch. The interpolation is not: compared with the exact solution of a crack bridged by linear springs (solved numerically for this tool) it is low by up to about 4 %, most near a = 2 Λ.

Margins of safety

The Load Level radio says whether the entered skin stress is ultimate or limit. Strength margins are written at ultimate load: patch tension over the crack against the patch strength, adhesive shear strain at the crack and at the patch end against the allowable strain, and skin tension at the patch end against Ftu. The skin yield margin at the patch end is written at limit load × FSyld. With a blended (thinned) skin and no crack, the stress in the remaining skin is checked the same way.

Guidance checks

The table of checks compares the design with values printed in the cited reports; each limit can be edited in Advanced mode. Stiffness ratio S between 1.0 and 1.2 (Sandia guidelines, eq. C-1: restore the stiffness of the skin, up to 20 % more). Overlap B at least 1.5 times the plastic transfer length fu tp / τp (eq. C-27), and at least six transfer lengths 1 / β (DOT/FAA/CT-92/32). The patch should extend at least 1 in beyond each crack tip. At 0.4 of the ultimate stress the adhesive strain at the crack should stay below twice the elastic limit (eqs C-19 and C-24), a simple screen for fatigue of the bond. A taper ratio is reported for a tapered end; no public rule was found for it, so a limit applies only if one is entered.

What it assumes

A flat, wide skin under uniform remote stress; an elliptical patch with the same Poisson's ratio as the skin, centered on the crack; a through crack across the load, fully covered and well inside the patch; a thin bond line acting in shear only, elastic-perfectly plastic; no bending (the skin is supported against the out-of-plane bending a one-sided patch causes); no disbond; patch properties taken along the load. The thermal residual stress follows the Sandia guideline equations by default (the full Ep εT added at the patch end, its share 1 / (1 + S) under the patch) or, by choice, a one-dimensional bonded strip; both are uniform under the patch and neither models the heated zone in two dimensions. The unpatched K is for an infinite sheet.

When it misleads

A one-sided patch on an unsupported thin skin bends, and the bending opens the crack on the unpatched face: K can be much higher than the value here. A disbond beside the crack lengthens the unsupported span of the patch and raises both K and the patch stress. Near stiffeners, cutouts, edges or other repairs the load attraction differs from the single ellipse in a wide sheet. A patch only a few transfer lengths long, or a crack that reaches the patch boundary, is outside the inclusion picture. Adhesive properties fall sharply when hot and wet and rise when cold; use values for the service condition. The thermal stress is an estimate: the true restraint during cure depends on the heating pattern and the surrounding structure, and measured residual strains should replace it when available. Rose's interpolation is slightly low for cracks near a = 2 Λ. Bond strength depends on surface preparation, which no calculation covers.

Not covered

Peel stress at the patch end, secondary bending, disbond growth, crack growth life, the residual strength of the cracked skin, rectangular or stepped patch planforms in detail, compression loading and buckling, orthotropic skins, cracks at holes or edges.

Material values

Defaults are illustrative. Boron-epoxy 5521/4 values (modulus 30 Msi, tensile strength 220 ksi, expansion coefficient 2.5 μin/in/°F, ply 0.0052 in) are from Table C-2 of the Sandia report. The adhesive (60 ksi, 6 ksi, γp = 2.0) is the ductile adhesive used as the default of the Adhesive Bonded Joint tool, from NASA CR-112235. The 2024-T3 strengths are MIL-HDBK-5J sheet values; its expansion coefficient (12.5 μin/in/°F) and the 175 °F cure temperature drop are round illustrative numbers. Enter the properties of the actual materials at the service temperature.




References

Roach, D., and Rackow, K. (2005). Development of Bonded Composite Doublers for the Repair of Oil Recovery Equipment. Sandia Report SAND2005-3195, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM.

Xiong, Y., Raizenne, D., and Simpson, D. (1997). "Analytical Approaches and Personal Computer (PC)-Based Design Package for Bonded Composite Patch Repair." In Bigelow, C. A. (ed.), Proceedings of the FAA-NASA Symposium on the Continued Airworthiness of Aircraft Structures, DOT/FAA/AR-97/2, Vol. I, Federal Aviation Administration, Washington, DC, pp. 37–50.

Atluri, S. N., Park, J. H., Punch, E. F., O'Donoghue, P. E., and Jones, R. (1993). Composite Repairs of Cracked Metallic Aircraft Structures. DOT/FAA/CT-92/32, FAA Technical Center, Atlantic City International Airport, NJ.

Hart-Smith, L. J. (1973). Adhesive-Bonded Double-Lap Joints. NASA Contractor Report 112235, Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA.

Rose, L. R. F. (1981). "An Application of the Inclusion Analogy for Bonded Reinforcements." International Journal of Solids and Structures, Vol. 17, pp. 827–838.

Rose, L. R. F. (1982). "A Cracked Plate Repaired by Bonded Reinforcements." International Journal of Fracture, Vol. 18, pp. 135–144.

Rose, L. R. F. (1988). "Theoretical Analysis of Crack Patching." In Baker, A. A., and Jones, R. (eds.), Bonded Repair of Aircraft Structures, Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht, pp. 77–106.

Vlot, A., Verhoeven, S., and Nijssen, P. J. M. (1998). Bonded Repairs for Aircraft Fuselages. Delft University Press, Delft.

Worked Examples

Published examples this tool reproduces; each page lists the inputs to enter and the printed answers.

All worked examples


DISCLAIMER: The methods and calculation on aNOWysis.com are provided as means to educate the reader. There is no warranty, expessed or implied, as to the relevance or accuracy of the methods or calculations. All calculations should be checked by a qualified analyst for appropriateness and accuracy. We will not be held liable for any damages, injuries or deaths caused by using methods or calculations from this site.