Tools › Structures › Joints › Bonded Patch Repair › Example

Bonded boron-epoxy patch over a 1 in crack in 2024-T3 skin by the Rose model: K reduced to 34 % (independent numpy check)

ToolBonded Patch Repair
SourceRoach, D., and Rackow, K. (2005). Development of Bonded Composite Doublers for the Repair of Oil Recovery Equipment. Sandia Report SAND2005-3195, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM. Appendix C, equations C-1, C-4, C-6, C-8 to C-13, C-17 and C-27, and Table C-2; Xiong, Y., Raizenne, D., and Simpson, D. (1997). "Analytical Approaches and Personal Computer (PC)-Based Design Package for Bonded Composite Patch Repair." In Proceedings of the FAA-NASA Symposium on the Continued Airworthiness of Aircraft Structures, DOT/FAA/AR-97/2, Vol. I, pp. 37–50, equations (7) and (9).
LevelProfessional

Problem

A 0.063 in 2024-T3 skin carries an ultimate stress of 30 ksi across a through crack 1 in long. A five-ply unidirectional boron-epoxy patch (0.026 in, 30 Msi), elliptical with half width 1.5 in along the crack and half length 2.0 in along the load, is bonded over it with a 0.005 in film adhesive (G = 60 ksi, plateau shear stress 6 ksi, plastic strain 2.0) cured 175 °F above ambient. Find the load the patch attracts, the residual stress from cure, the stress intensity factor with and without the patch at limit load, the adhesive shear strains and the margins of safety. The case is illustrative; no dimensional worked example of the Rose model was found in a public document, so the numbers are checked against an independent numpy calculation.

Inputs to Enter

  • Repair: Crack under the patch; Skin Stress 30 ksi (Ultimate), Half Crack Length 0.5 in; FS 1.5, FS_yld 1.15
  • Skin: thickness 0.063 in, modulus 10.5 Msi, CTE 12.5 μin/in/°F, F_tu 64 ksi, F_ty 47 ksi
  • Patch: thickness 0.026 in, modulus 30 Msi, CTE 2.5 μin/in/°F, tensile strength 220 ksi, half width 1.5 in, half length 2.0 in (boron-epoxy 5521/4, SAND2005-3195 Table C-2)
  • Adhesive: bond thickness 0.005 in, shear modulus 60 ksi, plastic shear stress 6 ksi, plastic shear strain 2.0; Cure Temp. Drop 175 °F
Open the Bonded Patch Repair tool (loaded with this example)

Answers

  • Stiffness ratio S = E_r t_r / (E_p t_p) = 1.179 (guidance 1.0 to 1.2: met); load-transfer length 1 / β = 0.1727 in
  • Skin stress under the patch φ = 0.5890 of the remote stress (numpy Eshelby inclusion 0.589002); load attraction at the patch end Ω_L = φ (1 + S) = 1.284
  • Thermal term E_p ε_T = 10.68 ksi with α_p (1 + ν) / 2 = 8.313 μin/in/°F, added at the patch end (eq. C-6); the skin under the patch keeps 1 / (1 + S) of it, 4.901 ksi (eq. C-8)
  • At limit load (20 ksi): σ_0 = 16.68 ksi, adhesive just past its elastic limit (P = 1.01), K∞ = 9.424 ksi√in, Λ = 0.1016 in
  • K without the patch 25.07 ksi√in; with the patch K_r = σ_0 √(π a Λ / (a + Λ)) = 8.592 ksi√in; reduction ratio 0.343
  • Adhesive shear strain at ultimate: 0.1442 at the crack, 0.1809 at the patch end, against 2.100 allowable
  • Margins: patch over the crack +0.85 (ULT), adhesive at the crack +13.57 and at the patch end +10.61 (ULT), skin at the patch end +0.30 (ULT) and +0.17 in yield (LIM)

Notes

The tool's default inputs are this case; press Submit. Asserted in test_bonded_patch_repair.php against References/Bonded-Patch-Repair/checks/patch_check.py. The thermal residual stress follows the guideline equations (the default); the bonded-strip alternative of Advanced mode gives K_r = 9.044 ksi√in and a skin yield margin of +0.59. Rose's interpolation is up to about 4 % below the exact solution of a crack bridged by linear springs; K∞ is the upper bound. Bending of the one-sided patch, disbonds and peel are not included.