Tools › Structures › Stress and Strain › Failure Theories › Example

Brittle material in tension and compression: maximum normal stress, Coulomb-Mohr and modified Mohr compared

ToolFailure Theories
SourceOriginal case. Budynas, R. G., and Nisbett, J. K. (2015). Shigley's Mechanical Engineering Design, 10th ed. McGraw-Hill Education, New York (the brittle Coulomb-Mohr and modified Mohr theories; cited for the method only).
LevelUndergraduate

Problem

A point in a brittle part has principal stresses of 70 MPa in tension and 200 MPa in compression, with a free surface. The strengths are 214 MPa in tension and 752 MPa in compression (illustrative values of the kind found for gray cast iron). Find the factor of safety against fracture by the three brittle theories.

Inputs to Enter

  • Principal stresses 70 MPa, −200 MPa and 0
  • Brittle material: S_ut = 214 MPa, S_uc = 752 MPa (illustrative)
Open the Failure Theories tool

Answers

  • Maximum normal stress: the smaller of 214 / 70 = 3.06 and 752 / 200 = 3.76, so n = 3.06
  • Brittle Coulomb-Mohr: n = 1 / (70 / 214 + 200 / 752) = 1.69
  • Modified Mohr (compression larger than tension, sloping line): n = 1 / ((752 − 214) · 70 / (752 · 214) + 200 / 752) = 2.00
  • The load line meets the three envelopes at (214, −611.4), (118.0, −337.2) and (140.0, −400.0) MPa

Notes

Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/stress-strain/failure-theories/?try=brittle-biaxial. The fourth quadrant is where the three theories differ most: the maximum normal stress theory ignores the compression acting beside the tension. Numbers checked in test_failure_theories.php against closed forms and an independent numpy calculation.

More Examples for This Tool