Tools › Civil and Geotechnical › Soils › Proctor Compaction Curve › Example
Modified against standard Proctor on one soil: the peak moves up and toward the dry side
| Tool | Proctor Compaction Curve |
| Source | original |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
The same silty clay is tested by the modified test (points by mass) and by the standard test (points as wet densities). How far apart are the two peaks?
Inputs to Enter
- Advanced mode. Modified test: mold 0.0333 ft³ and 9.35 lbm; mold + wet soil 13.397 / 13.623 / 13.786 / 13.788 / 13.686 lbm at 9.0 / 11.0 / 13.0 / 15.0 / 17.0 %
- Comparison test, standard: wet density 114.6 / 120.8 / 125.4 / 127.1 / 125.1 lb/ft³ at 12.5 / 14.6 / 16.4 / 18.3 / 20.4 %
- Specific gravity 2.70; least-squares cubic for both
Answers
- Modified: maximum dry density 117.5 lb/ft³ at 13.1 % (saturation 82 %)
- Standard: 107.9 lb/ft³ at 17.4 % (saturation 83 %)
- Difference 9.7 lb/ft³ and 4.3 points of water content; the standard maximum is 91.8 % of the modified maximum
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/civil/soils/proctor-compaction-curve/?try=more-energy-denser-and-drier. Illustrative readings. The modified test delivers 56,250 ft-lbf/ft³ against 12,375 for the standard test (FHWA NHI-06-088, Table 5-13); both peaks sit at about the same saturation.
More Examples for This Tool
- Standard Proctor test on a silty clay: five points, and a peak that depends on the curve drawn
- USBR 5500 laboratory compaction example: five specimens with moisture dishes, hand-drawn peak against fitted peaks
- A compaction point beyond the zero-air-voids line: a reading no soil can produce
- Field density tests against a compaction curve: one test at 93 % where 95 % is specified