Tools › Structures › Stability › Beam Column Cases › Method

Beam Column Cases: Method

Open the Beam Column Cases tool

Beam Column Cases: the 21 Tabulated Cases of NACA Technical Memorandum 985

What the tool does

A beam-column carries a longitudinal force and transverse loads at the same time. The longitudinal force acts on the deflection the transverse loads produce, so the bending moment is larger than the transverse loads alone would give, and it grows faster than the loads. NACA Technical Memorandum 985 (J. Cassens, translated from Luftfahrtforschung, 1941) collects the closed-form solutions of 21 such cases for a member of constant bending stiffness in one table: for each, the deflection line, the moment line, the constants A and B, the special moments (fixing moments, moment under the load, maximum moment) and the angle at which the member buckles. The tool lets you choose a case, enter the quantities drawn on its figure and read the solution written out step by step with the numbers substituted in every equation.

The equation behind every case

At a section x the moment is the moment M0x of the transverse loads and end moments on the undeflected member plus the longitudinal force times the deflection, Mx = M0x + P y. With Mx = −EI y″ this is EI y″ + P y = −M0x. The memorandum writes the solution with the length k = √(EI/P) and the angles φ = x/k and α = L/k (in radians):

Mx = A cos φ + B sin φ + (a constant for a uniform load),   P y = Mx − M0x.

The constants A and B follow from the end conditions. For a uniform load g on pinned ends (case 3), for example, A = g k², B = g k² tan(α/2), Mx = A cos φ + B sin φ − g k² and the maximum at the center is g k² (1/cos(α/2) − 1), which tends to g L²/8 as P tends to zero. In axial tension (offered for case 1) the sines and cosines become hyperbolic and the tension reduces the bending.

The cases

1 end moment on a pin-ended member (also in tension); 2 cantilever with an end load; 3 uniform load, pinned ends; 4 uniform load with end moments; 5 uniform load, one end fixed; 6 uniform load, both ends fixed; 7 uniform load on the center span of a three-span member whose side spans carry no longitudinal force; 8 member with an initial sine bow; 9 member with an initial parabolic bow; 10 to 12 the parabolic bow with a uniform load on pinned, fixed-pinned and fixed ends; 13 concentrated load with end moments; 14 and 15 concentrated load with one or both ends fixed; 16 concentrated load on the center span of three; 17 and 18 two and three concentrated loads; 19 uniform load over part of the length; 20 member with an overhang loaded at its free end; 21 a couple applied within the span.

Fixed ends and continuous supports are handled as the pin-ended member with unknown end moments, found from the end slopes: zero for a fixed end, and M Li/(3 E Ii) for an end held by an unloaded side span. An initial parabolic bow u = ξ (L x − x²) acts exactly like an added uniform load 2 P ξ, so cases 9 to 12 repeat cases 3, 5 and 6 with g + 2 P ξ in place of g. Several concentrated loads are the sum of single-load solutions at the same P, because the equation is linear in the transverse loads once P is fixed.

Buckling

Each row of the table ends with the angle α at which the denominators vanish and the member buckles: 90° for the cantilever, 180° for pinned ends, 360° for fixed ends, and the root of tan α = α (257.45°; the memorandum prints 257°30′) for one fixed and one pinned end. The buckling load is Pcr = αcr² E I / L². For the three-span cases and the overhang the angle depends on the dimensions; the tool finds the lowest root of the denominator the memorandum names ND. The formulas apply only below this load, and the tool refuses a larger one.

What it assumes

Constant E I along the member, small deflections, a longitudinal force that keeps its line of action, plane bending, and elastic material. Where the average stress P/A is beyond the proportional limit the memorandum uses the buckling (tangent) modulus in place of E; enter that value as E. Shear deformation is neglected.

Loads at limit or ultimate, and the margins

Allowables are optional. With a check selected, the loads are taken to ultimate before the analysis: entered limit loads (the longitudinal force, the transverse loads and the applied moments) are multiplied by the factor of safety first, because the moments of a beam-column are not proportional to its loads. The initial bow is a dimension and is not factored. The stress check compares P/A + M c/I, with the largest moment found anywhere on the member, with the entered allowable stress; the moment check compares that moment with an allowable moment; and the buckling margin is Pcr/P − 1. A positive margin on stress or moment does not mean the loads can grow in that proportion: near Pcr a small increase in load produces a large increase in moment.

Departures from the printed table

Case 20. The memorandum's expression for the moment over the first support has a/b in its denominator. Solving the differential equation for the overhang with the support rotation included gives k tan ζ / b in that place (ζ = a/k); the two agree when ζ is small. The tool uses the exact form and prints the memorandum's value beside it for comparison. Case 5. The buckling angle is taken as the root of tan α = α, 257.45°, where the table rounds to 257°30′. Symbols. The memorandum writes J for the moment of inertia and l for the length; the tool writes I and L, so that the two cannot be mistaken for each other. The figures are redrawn with the memorandum's symbols, loads positive as drawn.

Verification

The memorandum prints no numerical examples. Every case is checked against an independent finite-element model of the same member (cubic beam elements with the geometric stiffness of the longitudinal force): moments and deflections at 21 stations for two load levels, the named special moments, and the buckling load from the eigenvalue problem agree to within the discretization of that model. As P tends to zero the formulas return the familiar g L²/8, g L²/12, g L²/24 and Q L/8.

Limits

One member of constant section with one longitudinal force; transverse loads of the tabulated kinds only. For stepped members, several axial loads or arbitrary load sets use the Beam Column Strength tool; for a stringer with crippling use Beam-Column with Crippling. Local and lateral-torsional instability of the section are not checked.