Tools › Structures › Beams › Torsion of Bars and Shafts › Example
Hollow shaft against the solid shaft of the same weight: stress and stiffness
| Tool | Torsion of Bars and Shafts |
| Source | Original case (illustrative numbers); closed forms of mechanics of materials, checked in test-scripts/test_torsion_of_bars.php. |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
A hollow steel shaft 3 in outside and 2.5 in inside diameter, 48 in long (G = 11.5 Msi), carries 20,000 lb-in. Find its largest shear stress and twist, and compare with a solid shaft of the same material, length and weight.
Inputs to Enter
- Analyze: round shaft; torque 20,000 lb-in
- Outside diameter 3 in, inside diameter 2.5 in, length 48 in, shear modulus 11.5 Msi
Answers
- Hollow: J = π (3⁴ − 2.5⁴) / 32 = 4.117 in⁴; 7.286 ksi at the surface, 6.072 ksi at the bore; twist 1.162°
- Solid shaft of equal area: d = √(3² − 2.5²) = 1.658 in, J = 0.7424 in⁴, 22.34 ksi, twist 6.442°
- For the same weight the hollow shaft is 5.5 times as stiff, (do² + di²) / (do² − di²), and carries 32.6 % of the solid shaft's stress
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/beams/torsion-of-bars/?try=hollow-vs-solid. The gain is limited by the wall: a very thin tube buckles in shear before it yields, which the tool does not check.
More Examples for This Tool
- Thin-walled rectangular tube in torsion, closed and slit (NASA Astronautic Structures Manual example)
- Solid shaft sized from power and speed: torque, shear stress, twist and required diameter
- Stepped shaft fixed at both ends with a torque at the step: reactions by compatibility
- Rectangular bar in torsion: Saint-Venant coefficients, largest stress at the middle of the long side