Tools › Finance and Business › Auditing › Benford's Law Test › Example

When Benford's law does not apply: 600 rents within a narrow range

ToolBenford's Law Test
Sourceoriginal
LevelUndergraduate

Problem

A list holds 600 monthly rents between 1,681.69 and 3,211.04, centered near 2,450. Run the first-digit test and state whether Benford's law is an expectation for such data.

Inputs to Enter

  • Amounts: 600 seeded illustrative amounts (one per line); smallest amount 10
  • Test in full: first digit; significance level 5 %; no approval limit
Open the Benford's Law Test tool

Answers

  • The middle 90 % of the amounts run from 1,980.96 to 2,878.31, which is log10(2,878.31/1,980.96) = 0.16 orders of magnitude: less than the factor of ten an amount needs to run through every first digit once
  • The page states that Benford's law is not an expectation for these amounts and that the gaps are no reason to look at any entry
  • For the record, the first digit is 2 in 557 of 600 amounts (92.8 %) where the law puts 17.6 %: chi-square 2,343.72 on 8 degrees of freedom, mean absolute deviation 0.16716, 9 of 9 digits beyond ±1.96

Notes

Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/business/audit/benfords-law-test/?try=narrow-range. Seeded illustrative data. The one-order-of-magnitude screen is the tool's own rule, stated on the page and on its method page; it is not taken from a standard.

More Examples for This Tool