Tools › Structures › Fatigue › Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram › Example
Notched, machined part: notch factor 1.8, life by the Goodman, Smith-Watson-Topper and Morrow corrections
| Tool | Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram |
| Source | Original case. Kalluri, S., and McGaw, M. A. (1991). Effect of Tensile Mean Stress on Fatigue Behavior of Single-Crystal and Directionally Solidified Superalloys. NASA Technical Memorandum 103644, Lewis Research Center, Cleveland, OH. Equations (1) and (4); U.S. Department of Defense (2003). Metallic Materials and Elements for Aerospace Vehicle Structures. MIL-HDBK-5J, Department of Defense, Washington, DC. Equation 9.6.1.4(a). |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
A machined steel part (ultimate 100 ksi, yield 80 ksi) has a notch with a fatigue notch factor of 1.8. The nominal stress cycles between 4 and 36 ksi. With a surface factor of 0.85 on an endurance limit estimated as one-half of ultimate, and an assumed fatigue strength coefficient of 150 ksi, find the factors of safety and the life by three mean-stress corrections.
Inputs to Enter
- Advanced mode, USCS: maximum 36 ksi, minimum 4 ksi (nominal); notch factor 1.8 applied to the alternating and the mean stress
- Ultimate 100 ksi, yield 80 ksi; endurance limit 0.5 of ultimate; surface factor 0.85, other factors 1
- 0.9 of ultimate at 1,000 cycles, knee at 1,000,000 cycles; fatigue strength coefficient 150 ksi; Walker exponent 0.5
Answers
- σ_a = 1.8 × (36 − 4) / 2 = 28.8 ksi, σ_m = 1.8 × (36 + 4) / 2 = 36 ksi; S_e = 0.85 × 50 = 42.5 ksi
- Modified Goodman n = 0.964, Gerber 1.20, ASME-elliptic 1.23, Soderberg 0.887; first-cycle yield at the notch n_y = 80 / 64.8 = 1.23
- S-N line: b = log(42.5/90) / 3 = −0.1086, a = 190.6 ksi
- Goodman: σ_ar = 28.8 / (1 − 36/100) = 45 ksi → 591,000 cycles
- Smith-Watson-Topper: σ_ar = √(64.8 × 28.8) = 43.2 ksi → 860,000 cycles
- Morrow: σ_ar = 28.8 / (1 − 36/150) = 37.89 ksi, below the endurance limit → no failure predicted
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/fatigue/goodman-stress-life/?try=notched-part. The three corrections put the same cycle on either side of the endurance limit: near the knee of the S-N line a small change of equivalent stress changes the answer from a finite life to none. The surface factor and the fatigue strength coefficient are illustrative values, not handbook data.
More Examples for This Tool
- Steel part cycled between 5 and 75 ksi: Goodman says finite life, Gerber says infinite, and the S-N line gives 163,000 cycles
- High mean stress with a small ripple: inside the Goodman line but yielding on the first cycle
- Cycle from −60 to +20 ksi: how the fatigue criteria treat a compressive mean stress