Tools › Structures › Fatigue › Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram › Example
Cycle from −60 to +20 ksi: how the fatigue criteria treat a compressive mean stress
| Tool | Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram |
| Source | Original case. Figge, I. E. (1967). An Empirical Equation Relating Fatigue Limit and Mean Stress. NASA Technical Note D-3883, Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA. Appendix A (Gerber and Goodman equations) and p. 3 (the Gerber equation at negative mean stress). |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
The stress in a steel part (ultimate 100 ksi, yield 80 ksi, endurance limit 50 ksi) cycles between 60 ksi compression and 20 ksi tension. Find the factor of safety against fatigue and against yielding.
Inputs to Enter
- Simple mode, USCS: cycle entered as maximum 20 ksi and minimum −60 ksi
- Ultimate strength 100 ksi, yield strength 80 ksi; endurance limit estimated as 0.5 of ultimate
Answers
- σ_a = (20 + 60) / 2 = 40 ksi, σ_m = (20 − 60) / 2 = −20 ksi, R = −3, A = −2
- Fatigue: every criterion is replaced by the horizontal line σ_a = S_e, so n = 50 / 40 = 1.25 (no credit and no penalty for compression)
- Yield in compression: n_y = 80 / (40 + 20) = 1.33
- Equivalent fully reversed stress 40 ksi, below the endurance limit: no failure predicted
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/fatigue/goodman-stress-life/?try=compressive-mean. The Gerber parabola taken literally is symmetric and would give the same answer as for +20 ksi mean (n = 1.18); the Goodman line extended to the left would give n = 1.67. The horizontal line is common textbook practice, stated by the tool from memory.
More Examples for This Tool
- Steel part cycled between 5 and 75 ksi: Goodman says finite life, Gerber says infinite, and the S-N line gives 163,000 cycles
- High mean stress with a small ripple: inside the Goodman line but yielding on the first cycle
- Notched, machined part: notch factor 1.8, life by the Goodman, Smith-Watson-Topper and Morrow corrections