Tools › Structures › Fatigue › Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram › Example
Steel part cycled between 5 and 75 ksi: Goodman says finite life, Gerber says infinite, and the S-N line gives 163,000 cycles
| Tool | Stress-Life Fatigue and Goodman Diagram |
| Source | Original case. Criteria as written in Kalluri, S., and McGaw, M. A. (1991). Effect of Tensile Mean Stress on Fatigue Behavior of Single-Crystal and Directionally Solidified Superalloys. NASA Technical Memorandum 103644, Lewis Research Center, Cleveland, OH. Equations (1) to (3). |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
A steel part with an ultimate strength of 100 ksi and a yield strength of 80 ksi is loaded so that the stress at the critical point cycles between 5 ksi and 75 ksi. The endurance limit is estimated as one-half of the ultimate strength. Find the alternating and mean stress, the factor of safety for infinite life by the modified Goodman, Gerber, ASME-elliptic and Soderberg criteria, the factor against first-cycle yield and, if infinite life is not reached, the cycles to failure.
Inputs to Enter
- Simple mode, USCS: cycle entered as maximum 75 ksi and minimum 5 ksi
- Ultimate strength 100 ksi, yield strength 80 ksi; endurance limit estimated as 0.5 of ultimate (cap 100 ksi, not reached)
- S-N line: 0.9 of ultimate at 1,000 cycles, knee at 1,000,000 cycles (the Simple-mode values)
Answers
- σ_a = (75 − 5) / 2 = 35 ksi, σ_m = (75 + 5) / 2 = 40 ksi, R = 0.0667, A = 0.875; S_e = 0.5 × 100 = 50 ksi
- Modified Goodman n = 1 / (35/50 + 40/100) = 0.909; Soderberg n = 1 / (35/50 + 40/80) = 0.833
- Gerber n = 1.13; ASME-elliptic n = 1 / √((35/50)² + (40/80)²) = 1.16: the criteria disagree on infinite life
- First-cycle yield n_y = 80 / (35 + 40) = 1.07
- Goodman equivalent fully reversed stress σ_ar = 35 / (1 − 40/100) = 58.33 ksi
- S-N line: b = log(50/90) / 3 = −0.08509, a = 90² / 50 = 162 ksi; N = (58.33 / 162)^(1/b) = 163,000 cycles
Notes
The tool opens on this case; press Submit, or open it in the tool: /analysis-tools/structures/fatigue/goodman-stress-life/?try=finite-life. The numbers are checked against an independent root-search computation (References/Goodman-Stress-Life/checks). The one-half rule and the 0.9 fraction are textbook estimates for steel; the life is a mean value with no scatter factor.