Tools › Environmental › Groundwater › Water Chemistry Diagrams › Example

Charge-balance check: a decimal slip in sodium and a missing sulfate value

ToolWater Chemistry Diagrams
SourceHem, J. D. (1985). Study and Interpretation of the Chemical Characteristics of Natural Water, 3rd ed. U.S. Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 2254, U.S. Geological Survey, Alexandria, VA. Page 164 (cation-anion balance), Table 17 analysis 3 (page 102) and Table 10 (page 58). The two altered rows are original.
LevelUndergraduate

Problem

A well water is reported as Ca 49, Mg 18, Na 168, HCO3 202, SO4 44, Cl 246, NO3 2.2 mg/L. In a second copy of the row the sodium is typed as 16.8. A third row is another analysis (Ca 37, Mg 24, Na 611, HCO3 429, Cl 82 mg/L) whose sulfate, 1,010 mg/L, was left out. Compute the charge-balance error of each row against a tolerance of 2 %.

Inputs to Enter

  • Three rows in mg/L as stated; balance tolerance 2 %
Open the Water Chemistry Diagrams tool

Answers

  • As reported: cations 11.23, anions 11.20 meq/L, error 100 × (11.23 − 11.20) / (11.23 + 11.20) = +0.14 %: within the tolerance
  • Sodium typed 16.8: cations 4.657, anions 11.20 meq/L, error −41.27 %; the point moves from sodium chloride (Na + K 65.1 %) to calcium chloride (Ca 52.5 %)
  • Sulfate left out: cations 30.40, anions 9.345 meq/L, error +52.98 %; the water reads as sodium bicarbonate instead of sodium sulfate
  • Both altered rows stay on the Piper diagram, ringed in red

Notes

Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/environmental/groundwater/water-chemistry-diagrams/?try=decimal-slip-fails-balance. A negative error means anions in excess (a cation is missing or too low); a positive error the reverse. A balance within the tolerance does not prove an analysis right: two errors can cancel.

More Examples for This Tool