Tools › Electrical and Controls › Control Systems › Transfer Function Analyzer › Example
NASA CR-822 Example 1: Routh-Hurwitz test of the attitude-control characteristic equation s³ + 5s² + 24s + 20
| Tool | Transfer Function Analyzer |
| Source | Greensite, A. L. (1967). Analysis and Design of Space Vehicle Flight Control Systems, Volume III: Linear Systems. NASA Contractor Report CR-822, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, DC. Example 1, pp. 8–9, and Example 2, pp. 15–16. |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
The report's launch-vehicle attitude control system has the characteristic equation s³ + a_1 s² + a_2 s + a_3 = 0 with a_1 = 5, a_2 = 24 and a_3 = 20 for its parameter values. Decide whether it is stable, and whether any root has a relative damping factor below 0.5.
Inputs to Enter
- Numerator 1; denominator 1 5 24 20; gain K = 1 (only the characteristic equation is given in the example; the numerator does not affect the test)
- The whole system, as given
Answers
- Routh first column 1, 5, 20, 20: no sign change, so no root has a positive real part (report: the system is stable)
- The report's Hurwitz determinants are the running products of that column: H_1 = 5, H_2 = 5 · 20 = 100, H_3 = 100 · 20 = 2,000 (report: 5, 100, 2000)
- Roots −1 and −2 ± j 4; the pair has ω_n = 4.472 rad/s and ζ = 0.4472, below 0.5 (report, Example 2: a complex root pair whose relative damping factor is less than 0.5)
- A unity-feedback loop around it would stay stable up to a gain of 100 (gain margin 40 dB at 4.899 rad/s) (not in the report)
Notes
Enter the denominator 1 5 24 20, choose the whole system as given and press Submit. The report works the example with Hurwitz determinants; the tool writes the equivalent Routh array.
More Examples for This Tool
- Position servo K / (s(s + 1)(s + 2)) in a unity-feedback loop: stable range of K, margins, step response and root locus
- Standard underdamped second-order system 1 / (s² + s + 1): overshoot, peak time and settling time against the closed forms
- A right-half-plane zero, (1 − s) / ((s + 1)(s + 2)): the step response that starts the wrong way
- Routh array with a row of zeros: s³ + 2s² + 4s + 8 and its auxiliary polynomial
- Lead-compensated double integrator K (s + 1) / (s²(s + 10)): a type-2 loop that is stable for every gain
- An unstable plant made stable by feedback: K / ((s − 1)(s + 3)) and a gain margin below 1
- Routh array with a zero in the first column: s⁴ + s³ + 2s² + 2s + 3 and the ε method