Tools › Electrical and Controls › Control Systems › Transfer Function Analyzer › Example

Lead-compensated double integrator K (s + 1) / (s²(s + 10)): a type-2 loop that is stable for every gain

ToolTransfer Function Analyzer
SourceOriginal case, checked against numpy and scipy.signal; the largest phase lead asin((10 − 1) / (10 + 1)) at √10 rad/s is a closed form.
LevelUndergraduate

Problem

A double integrator 1 / s² (a body turned by a torque) cannot be stabilized by gain alone. With the lead compensator (s + 1) / (s + 10) the open loop is K (s + 1) / (s²(s + 10)). For K = 32 find the closed-loop poles, the phase margin, the step response and the steady-state errors, and the range of K that is stable.

Inputs to Enter

  • Numerator 1 1 (s + 1); denominator 1 10 0 0 (s³ + 10s²); gain K = 32
  • G(s) is the open loop, closed with unity feedback; input signal: unit step
Open the Transfer Function Analyzer tool

Answers

  • Characteristic polynomial s³ + 10s² + 32s + 32; with K as a symbol the s¹ entry is 9K / 10: stable for every K > 0
  • Closed-loop poles −2 and −4 (twice); zero at −1
  • Phase margin 54.9° at 3.194 rad/s (the largest lead, asin(9/11) = 54.9°, is at √10 = 3.162 rad/s); gain margin unlimited
  • Step response: overshoot 23.14 % (peak 1.231 at 0.9519 s) although no pole is complex; rise time 0.3552 s; settling time 2.625 s
  • Type 2: zero error to a step and to a ramp; K_a = 32 / 10 = 3.2 and a parabola error of 0.3125
  • Root locus: break points at s = −2.5 (K = 31.25) and s = −4 (K = 32); two asymptotes at ±90° from σ = −4.5

Notes

Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/electrical/controls/transfer-function-analyzer/?try=lead-compensator. The overshoot comes from the closed-loop zero at −1, which the second-order formulas do not account for.

More Examples for This Tool