Tools › Aerodynamics › Trajectories and Spaceflight › Atmospheric Entry Heating and Deceleration › Example
Allen and Eggers' own example: a 1-ft iron sphere falling straight down at 20,000 ft/s
| Tool | Atmospheric Entry Heating and Deceleration |
| Source | Allen, H. J., and Eggers, A. J., Jr. (1958). A Study of the Motion and Aerodynamic Heating of Ballistic Missiles Entering the Earth's Atmosphere at High Supersonic Speeds. NACA Report 1381, National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Washington, DC, pp. 2–4 (eqs. 7, 15 and 17; Figures 2 and 3). The density of iron (490 lb/ft³) is not given in the report. |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
A solid iron sphere 1 ft in diameter (drag coefficient 1) enters the atmosphere vertically at 20,000 ft/s from 40 miles up. With the report's atmosphere, ρ = 0.0034 exp(−y / 22,000) slug/ft³, find the maximum deceleration and its altitude and compare with the report's Figure 3; then include gravity.
Inputs to Enter
- Advanced mode, USCS: planet Earth with scale height 22,000 ft, reference density 0.10939 lb/ft³ (0.0034 slug/ft³), entry altitude 211,200 ft, K = 0.1113
- Entry speed 20,000 ft/s; entry angle 90° (straight down)
- Mass 256.6 lbm, diameter 1 ft, drag coefficient 1, nose radius 0.5 ft
Answers
- Ballistic coefficient 256.6 / (1 × 0.7854) = 326.7 lb/ft² (1,595 kg/m²)
- Eq. (17): maximum deceleration = V_E² sin θ_E / (2 e × 22,000 × 32.17) = 20,000² / 3,848,000 = 103.9 g (Figure 3, gravity neglected: about 105 g)
- Eq. (15): at y_1 = 22,000 ln(7.366) = 43,930 ft (13.39 km), where the speed is 0.61 V_E = 12,130 ft/s (Figure 3: peak near 45,000 ft)
- Numerical integration including gravity: 107.3 g at 43,730 ft (13.33 km), 3.2 % above the closed form, as the solid curve of Figure 3 lies above the dashed one
- Peak heat flux at the nose with the Sutton and Graves coefficient: 1,797 W/cm² (1,582 Btu/(ft²·s)) at 67,790 ft; the sphere reaches the ground after 23.9 s at 701 ft/s
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/aerodynamics/trajectories/atmospheric-entry/?try=iron-sphere. The report's curves for 10,000 and 30,000 ft/s give about 26 and 235 g; the tool gives 26.0 and 233.9 g. Values from Figure 3 are read from a graph. The report's own heating constant (6.8 × 10⁻⁶ in its units) is about half the Sutton and Graves value used here, as its footnote 9 anticipates.
More Examples for This Tool
- A return from the Moon flown without lift: 17 g where Apollo 10 saw 6.8 g
- A ballistic return from low orbit: why the closed form says 4 g and the capsule feels 8 g
- The Stardust sample return capsule: the fastest entry into Earth's atmosphere, 12.9 km/s
- Mars Pathfinder: a ballistic entry at 7.6 km/s into carbon dioxide
- A fist-size stony meteoroid at 20 km/s: 700 g and a heat flux no stone survives