Tools › Aerodynamics › Trajectories and Spaceflight › Atmospheric Entry Heating and Deceleration › Example
A return from the Moon flown without lift: 17 g where Apollo 10 saw 6.8 g
| Tool | Atmospheric Entry Heating and Deceleration |
| Source | Original case built on the entry state of Apollo 10: Graves, C. A., and Harpold, J. C. (1972). Apollo Experience Report: Mission Planning for Apollo Entry. NASA Technical Note D-6725, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, DC, p. 4 (weight 12,150 lb, trim drag coefficient 1.2891 above Mach 29.5) and pp. 17–18 (36,309 ft/s and −6.616° at the entry interface; first peak load factor 6.8 g). The diameter (12.83 ft) and nose radius (15.4 ft) are typed from memory and not checked against a source. |
| Level | Undergraduate |
Problem
A capsule with the mass and drag coefficient of the Apollo command module meets the atmosphere at 11,067 m/s (36,309 ft/s), 6.62° below the horizontal, the entry state of Apollo 10, but flies as a plain ballistic body with no lift. Find the peak deceleration, the peak heat flux at the stagnation point and the heat load, by the Allen and Eggers closed form and by numerical integration.
Inputs to Enter
- Planet Earth (exponential atmosphere fitted to the 1976 standard between 30 and 80 km: 0.859 kg/m³, scale height 7.52 km; entry altitude 121.92 km; K = 0.1113 for air)
- Entry speed 11,067 m/s, entry angle 6.62° below the horizontal
- Mass 5,511 kg, base diameter 3.911 m, drag coefficient 1.289, nose radius 4.694 m
Answers
- Ballistic coefficient β = m / (C_D A) = 5,511 / (1.289 × 12.01) = 355.9 kg/m²
- Closed form: n_max = V_E² sin γ_E / (2 e H g_0) = 11,067² × sin 6.62° / (2 × 2.718 × 7,520 × 9.807) = 35.22 g at 38.04 km
- Numerical integration with gravity and the curve of the planet: 16.80 g at 44.08 km, 95.2 s after entry; the path has flattened from 6.62° to 2.95° by then
- Peak heat flux at the nose: closed form 282.9 W/cm², numerical 208.6 W/cm² at 51.99 km (about 1,500 times full sunlight at Earth); heat load 11,260 J/cm²
- Above 5 g for 82.9 s; slowed to 221 m/s at 11.5 km after 216 s, 1,190 km downrange
- Twice the mass: the closed form gives the same 35.22 g; the numerical integration 14.70 g. Twice the nose radius: 147.5 W/cm²
Notes
Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/aerodynamics/trajectories/atmospheric-entry/?try=lunar-return. This is the tool's opening case. The real Apollo 10 command module flew with a lift-to-drag ratio of 0.30 and peaked at 6.8 g: the difference is what lift is for. Radiative heating, which matters at this speed, is not in the model. The closed form is off by a factor of two here because the entry is shallow.
More Examples for This Tool
- A ballistic return from low orbit: why the closed form says 4 g and the capsule feels 8 g
- The Stardust sample return capsule: the fastest entry into Earth's atmosphere, 12.9 km/s
- Mars Pathfinder: a ballistic entry at 7.6 km/s into carbon dioxide
- A fist-size stony meteoroid at 20 km/s: 700 g and a heat flux no stone survives
- Allen and Eggers' own example: a 1-ft iron sphere falling straight down at 20,000 ft/s