Tools › Finance and Business › Tax › S Corp versus Sole Proprietor › Example

S corporation at 400,000 of profit: a 40,000 salary gives a smaller deduction and more tax than 80,000

ToolS Corp versus Sole Proprietor
SourceOriginal illustrative case. Rules and 2026 figures: Internal Revenue Service (2025). Revenue Procedure 2025-32, sections 4.01, 4.14 and 4.26; Schedule SE (Form 1040) for 2026; Publication 15 for use in 2026; Form 8995-A (2025), Parts II to IV; Public Law 119-21, section 70105.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A single owner's business, not a specified service business and with no employees, earns 400,000 of net profit in 2026; there is no other income. Compare the federal tax as a sole proprietor with the tax as an S corporation that pays the owner 40,000 of salary and costs 3,000 a year to run. Find the qualified business income deduction in each structure.

Inputs to Enter

  • Net business profit 400,000; filing status single; other income 0; salary examined 40,000; yearly S corporation cost 3,000; no state payroll tax; not a service business
  • Tax year 2026 figures: standard deduction 16,100; 35 % bracket from 256,225 (58,448 of tax below it); wage base 184,500; business income threshold 201,750, phase-in range 75,000; minimum deduction 400
Open the S Corp versus Sole Proprietor tool (loaded with this example)

Answers

  • Sole proprietor: net earnings 400,000 · 0.9235 = 369,400; self-employment tax 0.124 · 184,500 + 0.029 · 369,400 = 33,590.60; Additional Medicare Tax 0.009 · 169,400 = 1,524.60
  • Sole proprietor deduction: taxable income 367,104.70 is above the range that ends at 276,750 and the business pays no W-2 wages, so the wage limit is 0 and the deduction is the 400 minimum; income tax 97,115.90; total 132,231.10
  • S corporation: payroll tax 2 · 0.0765 · 40,000 = 6,120; unemployment tax 42; pass-through profit 400,000 − 40,000 − 3,060 − 42 − 3,000 = 353,898
  • S corporation deduction: 20 % of 353,898 is 70,779.60 but 50 % of the 40,000 of wages is 20,000, so the deduction is 20,000; income tax 93,998.55; total with the yearly cost 103,160.55
  • Difference 29,070.55; the totals are equal at a salary of 356,278; the wage limit stops reducing the deduction at a salary of 110,991, and the total at a salary of 80,000 is 101,210, lower than at 40,000

Notes

The tool opens on this case; press Submit, or open it in the tool: /analysis-tools/business/tax/s-corp-versus-sole-proprietor/?try=low-salary-smaller-deduction. Federal tax only. The numbers are illustrative; the page does not say what salary is reasonable compensation. An illustration, not tax advice.

More Examples for This Tool