Tools › Finance and Business › Finance › Engineering Economy Factors › Example

Two machines with lives of 4 and 6 years: annual worth, least common multiple and incremental rate of return

ToolEngineering Economy Factors
Sourceoriginal
LevelUndergraduate

Problem

Machine A costs 12,000, costs 3,000 a year to run and is worth 1,500 after 4 years. Machine B costs 20,000, costs 2,200 a year to run and is worth 3,000 after 6 years. At 8 % a year, which is more economical if the service is needed indefinitely?

Inputs to Enter

  • Interest 8 % per year; Advanced mode, Compare with alternative B; find the uniform worth A
  • A: single −12,000 at 0; uniform −3,000, years 1 to 4; single +1,500 at 4
  • B: single −20,000 at 0; uniform −2,200, years 1 to 6; single +3,000 at 6
Open the Engineering Economy Factors tool

Answers

  • Present worth over each life: A −20,833.84 (4 years), B −28,279.83 (6 years): not comparable
  • Equivalent uniform worth: A −6,290.17 per year, B −6,117.36 per year
  • Present worth over 12 years (3 lives of A, 2 of B): A −47,403.20, B −46,100.91
  • Rate of return on the extra 8,000 for B: 11.018 % per year, above 8 %; all three views put B ahead

Notes

Open this case in the tool: /analysis-tools/business/finance/engineering-economy-factors/?try=two-machines-unequal-lives. Both comparisons assume each machine is replaced by an identical one at the same cost. Illustrative values; checked against repeated cash flows summed period by period.

More Examples for This Tool