Tools › Finance and Business › Economics and Damages › Prejudgment Interest and Present Value › Method
Prejudgment Interest and Present Value: Method
Open the Prejudgment Interest and Present Value tool
Prejudgment Interest and Present Value: Moving Money Through Time in a Damages Calculation
A damages figure usually has two time-value steps. Amounts lost in the past are brought forward to the judgment with interest, and a judgment that is paid late earns interest until it is paid. Amounts that will be lost in the future are brought back to the valuation date by discounting. The page does each step with every line shown. It supplies no rate: the rate, whether interest compounds, the date it starts and the discounting method are fixed by the statute, the contract or the court. It is an illustration of the arithmetic, not legal advice.
Interest on past amounts
Accounts. Every amount in the table is its own account. It bears interest from its own date, or from one date entered for all amounts (a judgment date, a demand date). Interest for a period from date a to date b is
interest = B × r × (days from a to b) / (days in the year)
where B is the balance that bears interest and r the annual rate. The first day of interest is the day after the start date and the end date is the last day. With a schedule of rates, each rate applies from its date until the date of the next line, and periods are split at those dates.
Day count. Actual/365 divides calendar days by 365, so a leap year earns 366/365 of the annual rate. Actual/actual divides each day by the length of its own calendar year, so a whole calendar year is exactly one year. 30/360 counts every month as 30 days and treats the 31st as the 30th (the variant known as 30E/360, which adds up exactly when a period is split; the bond-market variant differs by at most a day for periods that end on a 31st). Under 30/360 an amount that starts on the last days of a month has compounding periods of slightly unequal length around February.
Compounding. With simple interest B is the unpaid principal and interest never earns interest. With annual, quarterly or monthly compounding the interest accrued joins B on each anniversary, third month or month of the account's own start date (a date past the end of a short month falls on its last day); between those dates interest accrues by the day at the simple formula. Daily compounding multiplies B by (1 + r / days in the year) each day. A whole number of years of annual compounding therefore gives the familiar P(1 + r)n, as in Table 3 of the Federal Judicial Center's Reference Guide, which the page opens with: losses of 100 a year for ten years before trial at 7 percent come to 1,485 with simple interest and 1,578 with compound interest (the Guide prints 1,579, the sum of its rounded cells).
Federal postjudgment interest. 28 U.S.C. 1961(a) provides that interest on a money judgment in a civil case recovered in a district court "shall be calculated from the date of the entry of the judgment, at a rate equal to the weekly average 1-year constant maturity Treasury yield, as published by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, for the calendar week preceding the date of the judgment", and 1961(b) that it "shall be computed daily to the date of payment" (with stated exceptions) "and shall be compounded annually". On the page that is: one start date, annual compounding, and the rate of that week entered as a fixed rate. The statute does not name a day count. The weekly averages are published in the Board's H.15 data through its Data Download Program, and the federal courts' site keeps a page on the rate. Subsection (c) sets different rules for tax cases and for certain judgments against the United States. State prejudgment and postjudgment rates differ from state to state and change; none is built in.
Partial payments: the United States rule. A payment is applied on its date first to the interest then unpaid and only the remainder to principal. In Story v. Livingston, 38 U.S. (13 Pet.) 359, 371 (1839), the Supreme Court put it this way: "The correct rule in general is, that the creditor shall calculate interest whenever a payment is made. To this interest the payment is first to be applied; and if it exceed the interest due, the balance is to be applied to diminish the principal. If the payment fall short of the interest, the balance of interest is not to be added to the principal so as to produce interest." The page follows that: with several amounts, interest is paid on the oldest account first, then principal in the same order. Under compound interest, interest left unpaid by a small payment joins the balance at the next compounding date like any other accrued interest. A payment larger than the whole balance is reported as not applied.
The alternative: the Merchants' rule. For simple interest the page also prints the balance by the Merchants' rule, under which every amount and every payment carries simple interest to the end date and the two sums are netted. With simple interest it never gives a higher balance than the United States rule, because each payment is credited with interest for the whole remaining period. Which rule governs is a matter of law or contract.
Order on one date. Interest is accrued to the date, then compounded if the date is a compounding date, then new amounts are added, then payments are applied. The schedule table closes a row at each 1 January, each new amount, each change of rate and each payment. The daily figure printed after the balance is B × r / days in the year at the end date.
Present value of future amounts
The amount of year k of a stream, Ak, received t years after the valuation date, has the present value
PV = Ak × pk / (1 + i)t
with i the annual rate (an effective annual yield) and pk an optional probability. This is the formula of the Court's footnote 11 in Jones and Laughlin Steel Corp. v. Pfeifer: the present value of 1 due in n periods is 1 / (1 + i)n. Year 1 is the twelve months that begin at the valuation date. End-of-year timing sets t = k; mid-year timing sets t = k − ½, which suits amounts received through the year. A stream may stop part of the way through a year: the part year pays the matching fraction of the yearly amount at the end (or the middle) of that part.
Discount rate and growth. Each stream starts at its entered amount and grows at its own rate: Ak = A (1 + g)k − first year. A market rate goes with amounts that grow with inflation, a real rate with amounts in constant dollars; mixing the two is the classic error.
Net discount rate. When growth and discounting are folded into one number, n = (1 + i) / (1 + g) − 1, amounts are entered at today's level and discounted at n. A net rate of zero is the total offset method: growth and discount are taken to cancel and the present value is the plain sum of the amounts.
What the Supreme Court said in Pfeifer. The case arose under section 5(b) of the Longshoremen's and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act. The trial court had multiplied the worker's wage of 26,025 by his remaining 12½ working years (325,312.50) without discounting, following Pennsylvania's total offset rule in Kaczkowski v. Bolubasz, 491 Pa. 561, 421 A.2d 1027 (1980). The Court described the "real interest rate" approaches then in use (1.5 and 2 percent in two Second Circuit cases) and the total offset methods, of which it called Beaulieu v. Elliott, 434 P.2d 665 (Alaska 1967), "the seminal 'total offset' case" (462 U.S. at 541–544). It declined to make any one method mandatory in the federal courts, held that the trial court had erred in treating the state rule as a mandatory federal rule of decision, and added that it did not believe a trial court adopting a real-interest-rate approach in a suit under section 5(b) "should be reversed if it adopts a rate between 1 and 3% and explains its choice" (at 548–549). Parties may stipulate to total offset (at 550). The page opens with the facts of that case at a net rate of 2 percent, with the zero-rate (total offset) figure in the sensitivity table; the 2 percent is an example, and other statutes and state courts have their own rules. Citations other than these two, which the opinion gives, were not checked against the cited reports.
Probabilities. For a stream marked Applied, each year's amount is multiplied by the probability entered for that year (survival, or survival and labor-force participation for earnings). The page supplies no life or work-life table.
Sensitivity. The total is recomputed at the entered rate plus and minus one and two steps, and plotted over a range of rates. With a net rate the zero-rate row is always shown.
What it assumes
Dates are calendar dates of the Gregorian calendar; every amount and payment falls on a whole day. One rate applies to all amounts at any date. Compounding dates are counted from each account's own start date, not from calendar quarter or year ends. Payments are applied to accounts in order of their start dates. Future amounts fall once a year, at the end or the middle of the year, and the discount rate is the same for every year and every stream. Taxes on the interest or on the award are not considered, and the prejudgment and postjudgment periods are separate runs of the page: interest after judgment on a judgment that includes prejudgment interest is computed by entering the judgment total as one amount.
When it misleads
The arithmetic is exact; the entries are where the dispute lies. A statutory rate applied with compounding the statute does not allow, or from a date the law does not recognize, gives a precise wrong number. Day-count choices move the result by up to one day's interest per year, compounding choices by far more over long periods. Where a statute resets its rate periodically, a fixed rate misstates the interest: use the schedule. A calendar-anchored compounding rule (every 31 December, say) differs from the anniversary rule used here. For future amounts, a small change in the rate moves a long stream greatly (the chart shows how much), a nominal rate applied to constant-dollar amounts understates the present value, and a total offset result is only as sound as the premise that growth and discount cancel for the person and period at hand. Probabilities entered for the average person may not describe the plaintiff.
Checks
The library is tested against Tables 1, 2 and 3 of the Reference Guide on Estimation of Economic Damages, the figures printed in the Pfeifer opinion (325,312.50; 275,881.36; 2,318 as the present value of 7,200 ten years out at 12 percent), hand arithmetic for each day count, compounding rule and payment rule, closed-form annuities, and an independent computation that accrues interest one calendar day at a time with Python's date arithmetic.