Tools › Structures › Thin-Walled Structures › FEA Batch Margins › Example
Batch of 18 pasted shell-element force rows: governing panel in compression and shear, M.S. −0.13 in buckling (independent numpy check)
| Tool | FEA Batch Margins |
| Source | Gerard, G., and Becker, H. (1957). Handbook of Structural Stability. Part I: Buckling of Flat Plates. NACA Technical Note 3781, National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Washington, DC. Equation (1), equation (55) and Table 5 (R_c + R_s² = 1). |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
Six shell elements in two panel groups (10 × 5 × 0.050 in and 8 × 8 × 0.063 in, 2024-T3 sheet, all edges simply supported) each carry three load cases of ultimate membrane forces N_x, N_y, N_xy pasted as 18 plain rows. Find the margin of safety of every element and case in buckling, tension, shear and yield, the lowest margin and the governing load case of each element. The force set is an illustration made for the tool, not output of a real model; the expected values are from an independent numpy and scipy computation, not from a printed example.
Inputs to Enter
- Analysis: Panels; forces pasted as ID, case, N_x, N_y, N_xy in lb/in (the default text); pasted forces are Ultimate; FS 1.5, FS_yld 1.15
- Property rows: IDs 101–103, a = 10 in, b = 5 in, t = 0.050 in; IDs 201–203, a = 8 in, b = 8 in, t = 0.063 in
- E_c 10.7 Msi, ν 0.33, F_cy 39 ksi, Ramberg-Osgood n 20, F_tu 64 ksi, F_ty 47 ksi, F_su 39 ksi; simply supported edges; plasticity factors on
- Governing row: element 103, case 1: N_x = −210 lb/in, N_y = 0, N_xy = 100 lb/in
Answers
- Row 1 allowables: k_x = 4.00, F_cr,x = 3.950 ksi; k_s = 6.55 (independent Ritz solution 6.546), F_s,cr = 6.465 ksi
- Element 103, case 1: f_x = −4.200 ksi, τ = 2.000 ksi; R_b = 4.200 / 3.950 = 1.063, R_s = 2.000 / 6.465 = 0.3094
- λ = 2 / (R_b + √(R_b² + 4 R_s²)) = 0.8721 (elastic: plasticity factor 1); M.S. buckling = −0.13 (numpy −0.1279), ULT
- Same row: principal tension M.S. +79.0, maximum shear +12.45 (ULT), von Mises yield +8.34 (LIM)
- Second negative row: element 203, case 2 (N_x = N_y = −50, N_xy = −260 lb/in), biaxial compression plus shear, M.S. −0.10 (numpy −0.1039)
- Summary: 18 rows, 6 elements, 3 load cases; 2 negative rows in 2 elements; element 203 case 3 (tension in both directions, no shear) reports no buckling
Notes
The tool's default inputs are this case; press Submit. Every margin of the 18 rows is asserted against References/FEA-Batch-Margins/checks/fea_batch_check.py in test_fea_batch_margins.php (buckling within 0.4 % of 1 + M.S., the difference being the site's shear-coefficient table against the Ritz solution; strength and yield margins to 1e-10).