Tools › Structures › Loads and Dynamics › Force Limited Vibration › Example
Force limits for the CRIS instrument on the ACE spacecraft: simple and complex two-degree-of-freedom models and the semi-empirical limit (NASA-HDBK-7004B Appendix C)
| Tool | Force Limited Vibration |
| Source | National Aeronautics and Space Administration (2003). Force Limited Vibration Testing. NASA-HDBK-7004B, 31 January 2003. Appendix C, Force Specification Example (p. 29); National Aeronautics and Space Administration (2012). Force Limited Vibration Testing. NASA-HDBK-7004C, 30 November 2012. Eqs. 2a, 2b (p. 29), Appendix B Eqs. B1, B2 (p. 57), Appendix C Table 3 (p. 60); Scharton, T. D. (1997). Force Limited Vibration Testing Monograph. NASA Reference Publication RP-1403, Eqs. 22–26. |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
A 66 lb instrument (CRIS) is mounted on a honeycomb panel of the ACE spacecraft whose effective weight seen from the interface is 400 lb. For a random vibration test normal to the panel, with the acceleration specification rising from 0.01 g²/Hz at 40 Hz to 0.12 g²/Hz at 160 Hz and 0.16 g²/Hz from 400 to 800 Hz, derive the force specification in one-third-octave bands by the simple two-degree-of-freedom method, the complex two-degree-of-freedom method (Q = 20) and the semi-empirical method with C = 1.5 and a break frequency of 200 Hz, as the spreadsheet in Appendix C of revision B of the handbook does (the example is not printed in revision C).
Inputs to Enter
- Force Limit By: Two-DOF models, masses from asymptotes; Simple-Model Masses: Residual only (7004B example)
- Acceleration specification (Hz, g²/Hz): 40 0.01; 50 0.015; 63 0.025; 80 0.04; 100 0.063; 125 0.1; 160 0.12; 315 0.12; 400 0.16; 800 0.16; 1000 0.1 (the exact values behind the two-figure values printed in the appendix)
- Test item: total mass 66 lbm, fundamental (break) frequency 200 Hz, C² 2.25, roll-off exponent n = 1, load residual mass constant to 160 Hz then falling as 1/f
- Source: 400 lbm, residual mass constant to 50 Hz then falling as 1/f²; model Q 20
- Notch estimate: amplification Q 20, modal mass fraction 0.2
Answers
- Simple model with residual masses, lb²/Hz, 40 to 1,000 Hz: 389.96, 584.94, 684.31, 777.94, 915.19, 1,119.62, 1,049.57, 609.90, 357.80, 207.99, 159.93, 96.50, 57.67, 34.16, 13.18 (book: the same fifteen values)
- At 40 Hz: M_2/M_1 = 66/400 = 0.165, (ω/ω_0)² = 0.6680, normalized force 8.952, limit = 8.952 × 66² × 0.01 = 389.96 lb²/Hz
- Semi-empirical, C = 1.5: 98.01 lb²/Hz at 40 Hz, 1,176.12 lb²/Hz at 160 and 200 Hz, 752.72 at 250 Hz, 39.20 at 1,000 Hz (book: the same); overall 580.68 lb rms (tool)
- Complex model at 200 Hz (μ = 2.112, α_1 = 0.5625, α_2 = 0.25): normalized force 6.122, limit 2,047.91 lb²/Hz (book: 2,007.24, from the whole-number table value 6)
- Complex model 250 to 1,000 Hz: tool 1,397.33, 919.51, 756.00, 418.74, 267.46, 168.48, 69.40 lb²/Hz; book 1,284.64, 891.76, 759.41, 457.58, 276.92, 176.12, 70.91 (table interpolation; within 9 %)
- Larger of the two models: simple below 200 Hz, complex from 200 Hz; overall 743.74 lb rms (tool)
- With the tool's default option (asymptotic masses for the simple model, as revision C recommends) the simple-model limits become 389.96, 584.94, 974.90, 1,094.89, 1,225.26, 1,452.68, 1,343.54, 1,049.57 lb²/Hz from 40 to 200 Hz and the overall larger-model force 769.57 lb rms (tool; no printed counterpart)
- Estimated notch at 200 Hz for Q = 20 and a modal mass fraction of 0.2: 6.4 dB with the two-degree-of-freedom limit, 8.8 dB with the semi-empirical limit (tool; the handbook reports a 7 dB notch in the CRIS test)
Notes
Open the tool, set Simple-Model Masses to Residual only (7004B example) and press Submit; every other input is the default. The simple-model and semi-empirical rows then match the printed digits (test_force_limited_vibration.php). The spreadsheet of revision B interpolates the whole-number table for the complex model, while the tool evaluates RP-1403 Eqs. 22–26 directly (which reproduce 1,509 of 1,512 cells of Tables 2–4 of NASA-HDBK-7004C), so the complex-model limits differ from the printed ones by up to 9 %. Revision C recommends asymptotic masses for the simple model; the tool's estimate of them (residual plus modal mass of the band) and its notch estimate are the tool's own and have no printed counterpart beyond the measured 7 dB.