Tools › Structures › Joints › Preloaded Joint (NASA-STD-5020) › Example
NASA-STD-5020B Appendix A.2: preload variation from 30 torque-tension tests (Γ = 0.644, 0.353 and 0.498 at 90/95) and the preload range it gives a 1/4-28 bolt
| Tool | Preloaded Joint (NASA-STD-5020) |
| Source | National Aeronautics and Space Administration (2021). Requirements for Threaded Fastening Systems in Spaceflight Hardware. NASA-STD-5020B, Office of the NASA Chief Engineer, Washington, DC. Appendix A.2, Tables 5 and 6 and Eqs. 31 to 36 (pp. 46 to 50); Sections 4.3.1 and 4.4 for the margins. |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
Ten sets of 3/8 in fastening hardware are each torqued three times to 450 in-lb in the as-received condition and the preload is measured (Table 6 of the standard, 30 values from 3,054 to 7,760 lb). Find the mean preload, the extreme variations Γ_a-max and Γ_a-min, the sample standard deviation and the preload variation at 90 percent probability and 95 percent confidence. Then apply the 90/95 variation to the page's default joint: a 1/4-28 bolt of 160 ksi torqued to 100 ± 5 lb-in with a nut factor of 0.15, four fasteners, 1,000 lb limit tension and 500 lb limit shear per fastener.
Inputs to Enter
- Preload From: Torque; Γ at 90/95 from pasted tests. Test Preloads: the default text, which is Table 6 of the standard (30 values)
- All other inputs at their defaults: D 0.25 in, pitch 0.0357 in, F_tu 160 ksi, F_ty 120 ksi, F_su 95 ksi, torque 100 ± 5 lb-in, K_nom 0.15, n_f 4, relaxation 5 percent, φ 0.25, n 0.5, limit loads, FS 1.5, FS_yld 1.15, FF 1.15
Answers
- Mean preload 4,720.6 (standard: 4,721 lb); Γ_a-max = 7,760 / 4,721 − 1 = 0.644; Γ_a-min = 1 − 3,054 / 4,721 = 0.353 (standard: 0.644 and 0.353)
- Sample standard deviation 1,097.0 (standard: 1,097 lb); tolerance factor s = 2.145 for 30 tests (Table 5); Γ_90/95 = 2.145 × 1,097 / 4,721 = 0.498 (standard: 0.498)
- Library check of the nut factor with the test torque and diameter: K_nom = 450 / (0.375 × 4,721) = 0.254 (standard: 0.254); the page keeps the entered K_nom
- Default joint with Γ = 0.4984 (tool): P_pi-max = 1.05 × 1.4984 × 2,667 = 4,196 lb; P_pi-min by Eq. 5 = 0.95 × (1 − 0.4984 / √4) × 2,667 = 1,902 lb; P_p-min = 0.95 × 1,902 = 1,807 lb
- P′_sep = 4,196 / (1 − 0.125) = 4,795 lb, P′_tu = (5,821 − 4,196) / 0.125 = 13,000 lb: separation before rupture, M.S. ultimate tension = 5,821 / (1.15 × 1.5 × 1,000) − 1 = +2.37
- P′_ty = (4,365 − 4,196) / 0.125 = 1,358 lb is below P′_sep: yield before separation (Eq. 16), M.S. yield = 1,358 / (1.15 × 1.15 × 1,000) − 1 = +0.03
- M.S. separation = 1,807 / 1,000 − 1 = +0.81; shear +4.41; combined shear and tension (Eq. 20) +1.89
Notes
Select the preload option above and press Submit. The six statistics are the standard's printed values (it notes that the scatter of this sample is unusually high); they are asserted to the printed digits in test_preloaded_joint_nasa_5020.php. The joint margins are the tool's results for its own illustrative default joint, checked against an independent numpy computation, not numbers printed in the standard, which contains no worked margin example. With the alternate method (larger of the entered Γ and the test extremes) the same data put the maximum preload above the yield allowable.