Tools › Structures › Damage Tolerance › Stress Intensity Factors › Example

Surface crack a/c = 0.4, a/t = 0.4 in tension and bending: the Newman–Raju equation against the finite-element table of NASA TP-1578

ToolStress Intensity Factors
SourceNewman, J. C., Jr., and Raju, I. S. (1984). Stress-Intensity Factor Equations for Cracks in Three-Dimensional Finite Bodies Subjected to Tension and Bending Loads. NASA Technical Memorandum 85793, Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA. Equations (14)–(25); Newman, J. C., Jr., and Raju, I. S. (1979). Analyses of Surface Cracks in Finite Plates Under Tension or Bending Loads. NASA Technical Paper 1578, Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA. Table I, p. 20.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A plate 0.25 in thick and 2.5 in wide carries a semi-elliptical surface crack 0.1 in deep and 0.5 in long (a/c = 0.4, a/t = 0.4, c/b = 0.2) under 20 ksi of tension and 10 ksi of outer-fiber bending, both limit. Find the boundary-correction factors at the deepest point and at the surface, the largest stress intensity, the margin against a toughness of 30 ksi√in and the critical crack size at the same aspect ratio.

Inputs to Enter

  • Crack case: surface crack in a plate; a = 0.1 in, c = 0.25 in, t = 0.25 in, W = 2.5 in
  • Tension stress 20 ksi, bending stress 10 ksi, load level Limit; toughness 30 ksi√in (an example value, not a named alloy)
Open the Stress Intensity Factors tool (loaded with this example)

Answers

  • Q = 1 + 1.464 (0.4)^1.65 = 1.323
  • Deepest point (φ = 90°): F = 1.246 (TP-1578 finite-element value 1.225), H F = 0.642 (finite-element 0.629)
  • Surface point (φ = 0°): F = 0.911 (finite-element 0.896), H F = 0.771 (finite-element 0.755)
  • K = (S_t + H S_b) √(π a / Q) F: 15.27 ksi√in at the deepest point (12.14 tension + 3.13 bending), 12.63 ksi√in at the surface
  • Margin at limit load 30 / 15.27 − 1 = +0.96; loads at fracture 39.3 ksi tension with 19.6 ksi bending
  • Critical crack size at a/c = 0.4: a = 0.2253 in (c = 0.563 in), found by root search on K = 30 ksi√in

Notes

The tool's default inputs are this case; press Submit. The geometry is one cell of the report's finite-element table, so the page's F and H F can be read against printed values (the equation is within 2 % here; over the whole table it is within 7 % in tension and 8 % in bending). The toughness, margin and critical size are the tool's own arithmetic (test_stress_intensity_factors.php, checked against a scipy root), not numbers printed in the reports.