Tools › Structures › Composites › Sandwich Panel Inserts › Example
Sandwich panel loaded at an insert: core shear coefficient k3 = 0.54 and the 1,900 lb load of MIL-HDBK-23A chapter 20
| Tool | Sandwich Panel Inserts |
| Source | U.S. Department of Defense (1974). Structural Sandwich Composites. MIL-HDBK-23A, Change Notice 3, Washington, D.C. Chapter 20, formulas (20:1) to (20:7), example 1 (p. 20-5) and figure 20-2 (p. 20-8). |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
A circular sandwich panel of 25 in radius has 0.080 in facings (E = 10,000,000 psi, Poisson's ratio 0.3) on a 1.12 in core with shear modulus 2,000 psi and a core shear design stress of 60 psi. An insert carries a normal load of 1,900 lb. The handbook finds φa = 40, an insert radius of 2.28 in (b/a = 0.091) and the maximum core shear stress coefficient k3 = 0.54 from its chart. Reproduce the coefficient and the load at which the core shear stress reaches 60 psi.
Inputs to Enter
- Input Mode Advanced; Insert Type: through the thickness; Insert Diameter 4.55 in; Potting Radius: Entered, effective and real radius 2.275 in
- Face sheet thickness 0.08 in, modulus 10 Msi, Poisson's ratio 0.3; Core Height 1.12 in
- Shear Modulus (W) 2 ksi with Modulus Factor 1; Shear Str. (W) 60 psi with Strength Factor 1 (the handbook's values are used directly)
- Shear Coefficient: Bessel-function solution, panel radius entered; Panel Radius 25 in
- Normal Load 1,900 lb, In-Plane Load 0, Load Level Ultimate
Answers
- Stiffness ratio α = 1.657 1/in, α b_p = 3.77 (MIL-HDBK-23A's φ = 1.600 1/in, φa = 40: the two definitions differ by the factor √(d I / (c I_p)))
- K_max = 0.5471 from the Bessel-function solution at the entered panel radius (book: k3 = 0.54 read from figure 20-2; with φ in place of α the same solution gives 0.5399)
- Handbook exponential approximation of K_max: 0.5161, 5.7 % below the Bessel value, because α b_p is below 5
- Load at a core shear stress of 60 psi: P_crit = 1,884 lb (book: 1,900 lb design load, the insert sized to carry it)
- M.S. = 1,884 / 1,900 − 1 = −0.01
Notes
Not the tool's default case. The test script (test_sandwich_panel_inserts.php) asserts k3 = 0.54 within the chart-reading tolerance for the library's Bessel solution with the handbook's φ, five further readings of figure 20-2, and this page case. The tool's own stiffness ratio is that of the ESA Insert Design Handbook (ECSS-E-HB-32-22A), which is why its coefficient is 1.3 % above the chart value.