Tools › Project Management › Cost › Benefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost › Method

Benefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost: Method

Open the Benefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost tool

Benefit-Cost Analysis and Life-Cycle Cost Analysis: The Two Federal Methods

Both methods put costs and savings that fall in different years on one footing by discounting, and both work in constant (real) dollars of a base year with a real discount rate. They answer different questions. A benefit-cost analysis asks whether a project is worth its cost to the public; a life-cycle cost analysis asks which of two designs that do the same job is cheaper to own. The page is an illustration of the methods with the entered rates and amounts, not advice.

Discounting

A flow of amount A that falls t years after the base year has the present value A / (1 + i)t, i being the real discount rate; a flow in the base year is not discounted (USDOT guidance, Appendix B; OMB Circular A-94, Appendix B). When a year's costs and benefits arrive as a steady stream, Circular A-94 advances them six months: the end-of-year present value is multiplied by √(1 + i), which is the mid-year option of the page (flows of the base year stay undiscounted). Amounts must be stated in base-year dollars and discounted with a real rate, or in year-of-expenditure dollars with a nominal rate, never mixed (A-94, Sections 7 and 8).

Which rate. Circular A-94 as OMB lists it in November 2026 is the text of 29 October 1992: 7 percent real for public investment and regulatory analysis (Section 8.b), and the real Treasury borrowing rates of its Appendix C for cost-effectiveness and lease-purchase analysis (1.1 to 2.0 percent in the appendix revised 6 March 2026). The revision of 9 November 2023, which set 2.0 percent (3.1 percent with a risk premium), is no longer the listed text. The USDOT guidance of December 2025 (for fiscal year 2026 applications, Section 4.3) tells applicants to use 7 percent real, to state every amount in 2024 dollars and to discount to 2024; the rate and the base year are entries, so that another funding notice can be followed. Federal energy and water projects under 10 CFR 436 use the DOE rate published each year in the Annual Supplement to NIST Handbook 135: 3.0 percent real for 2025 (the floor of the rule).

Benefit-cost analysis

Each row of the stream table is an amount per year between two calendar years, optionally growing at a constant real rate; costs and benefits are measured against the no-build case. With PVben, PVcap, PVom and PVres the present values of the benefits, the capital costs, the net change in operating and maintenance cost and the residual value:

NPV = PVben − PVcap − PVom + PVres

BCR = (PVben − PVom + PVres) / PVcap

The ratio follows Section 7 of the USDOT guidance: where projects compete for a fixed budget, the denominator holds only the upfront capital cost, and net operating and maintenance costs and the residual value are added to or subtracted from the numerator. A ratio with every cost in the denominator is printed beside it; the two agree on which side of 1 the project falls, and the net present value does not depend on the bookkeeping at all. The internal rate of return is the rate at which the NPV is zero, found by scanning from −95 to 1,000 percent and bisecting every sign change; when the yearly net flow changes sign more than once there can be several, and the page lists them all. A-94 treats the rate of return as information and the NPV as the criterion. The discounted payback year is the first year in which the cumulative discounted net flow is back at or above zero.

Residual value. An asset whose service life U outlasts the Y years of operation in the analysis keeps, by straight-line depreciation, the value cost × (U − Y) / U at the end; it is entered in the last year and discounted (USDOT guidance, Section 6.3 and the Appendix B example: 40 million, 40-year life, 30 years of operation, 10 million).

Monetized benefits. The helper multiplies yearly quantities (fatalities and injuries avoided, hours saved, vehicle-miles, tons of emissions) by unit values and adds the products as benefit streams. The unit values that open in the form are those of Appendix A of the USDOT guidance of December 2025, in 2024 dollars: 13,700,000 for a fatality avoided and 1,302,300, 256,300 and 122,400 for injuries of KABCO levels A, B and C; 9,700 for a property-damage-only crash; 21.80 an hour for travel time of all purposes and 37.20 for a truck driver; 0.56 and 1.23 a mile for light-duty vehicles and commercial trucks; 21,600, 59,000 and 1,054,000 a metric ton for NOx, SOx and PM2.5 in 2025. USDOT reissues the tables every year: use the edition named in the funding notice. The emissions table gives a value for each year (rising to 2030, constant after); the form holds one value. That edition gives no value for carbon dioxide.

Sensitivity. The table recomputes NPV and BCR with the cost streams (capital and operating) and the benefit streams raised and lowered by the entered percentage, with both moved against the project, and at a second discount rate. The switching values are the single factors on benefits, or on costs, that bring the NPV to zero.

Life-cycle cost analysis (NIST Handbook 135)

Costs are entered at base-date prices and brought to present value with three factors (Handbook 135, Chapter 3): SPVt = 1 / (1 + d)t for a single cost in year t; UPVN = [(1 + d)N − 1] / [d (1 + d)N] for a cost that recurs every year of the study period N; UPV*N = (1 + e)/(d − e) · [1 − ((1 + e)/(1 + d))N] (N when e = d) for a yearly cost whose price escalates at the constant real rate e. For energy the federal method does not use a constant rate: the Annual Supplement tabulates FEMP UPV* factors built from the Department of Energy's price projections by fuel, region and rate type, the sum of the projected price indices over (1 + d)t. The page takes such a factor as an entry, or builds one from entered yearly indices, or falls back on the constant-rate formula. The supplement's factor tables are in its companion spreadsheet and are not reproduced here.

LCC = I0 + Repl − Res + E + W + OM&R (eq. 7-1), every term a present value. For an alternative A against a base case BC (Chapter 6):

NS = LCCBC − LCCA = [ΔE + ΔW + ΔOM&R] − [ΔI0 + ΔRepl − ΔRes]

SIR = [ΔE + ΔW + ΔOM&R] / [ΔI0 + ΔRepl − ΔRes]

AIRR = (1 + r) · SIR1/N − 1

with the operational savings taken as base case minus alternative and the investment-related differences as alternative minus base case; r is the reinvestment rate, the discount rate in the FEMP measure. The payback year (eq. 6-12) is the first year at which the cumulative yearly savings, less later replacement differences, cover the additional initial investment: undiscounted for the simple payback, discounted for the discounted payback. The screening form ΔI0 / (first-year savings) is eq. 6-13. Handbook 135 computes with factors rounded to three decimals; the page offers that rounding so that a hand calculation from the printed tables is reproduced to the dollar (Example 5-1: 643,212 and 599,409), and otherwise carries full precision (643,221.02 and 599,418.45).

What it assumes

Year-end (or mid-year) lump flows; one real discount rate for the whole period; amounts already in base-year dollars; growth and escalation at constant rates unless yearly indices are entered; residual value by straight-line depreciation; benefits and costs measured against a no-build or base case that the user has defined consistently; in the life-cycle cost method, both cases delivering the same service over the same study period, with operation starting at the base date (no planning or construction period).

When it misleads

When benefits are counted twice (travel-time savings and the land-value gains that capitalize them), or transfers such as taxes, tolls and local jobs are booked as benefits. When the no-build case is unrealistic. When the benefit-cost ratio is used to rank projects of different size or compared across analyses that book operating costs differently: the NPV is the measure that does not depend on the bookkeeping. When several internal rates of return exist. When the savings-to-investment ratio, the AIRR or payback are used to choose among mutually exclusive designs: only the lowest life-cycle cost (highest net savings) does that; the ratio ranks independent projects for a limited budget. When a payback year is read as a life-cycle result: it ignores everything after it. When a constant escalation rate stands in for the projected energy prices of the Annual Supplement. When the monetized unit values are of another year than the dollars of the analysis, or of a superseded edition. The page does not treat uncertainty beyond the sensitivity table, distributional effects, non-monetized effects, taxes, financing, or the agency-specific rules of FEMA, USDOT or DOE programs beyond those cited.