Tools › Project Management › Cost › Benefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost › Example

USDOT guidance Table B-1: discounting travel-time savings and construction costs at 7 %, NPV and benefit-cost ratio

ToolBenefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost
SourceU.S. Department of Transportation (2025). Benefit-Cost Analysis Guidance for Discretionary Grant Programs. Office of the Secretary, December 2025, Washington, DC. Appendix B, Table B-1 (p. 52); Section 4.3 (p. 12) for the 7 percent real rate and the 2024 base year; Section 7 (p. 35) for the benefit-cost ratio.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A project costs 38.5 million dollars in 2024 and 15.5 million in 2025 and yields travel-time savings of 23,341,500, 24,570,000, 25,061,400 and 26,781,300 dollars in 2026 to 2029, all in 2024 dollars. Discount each stream to 2024 at a real rate of 7 percent, and find the net present value and the benefit-cost ratio with only capital costs in the denominator.

Inputs to Enter

  • Base year 2024, real discount rate 7 %, end-of-year amounts
  • Capital cost: 38,500,000 in 2024; 15,500,000 in 2025
  • Benefit (value of travel time savings): 23,341,500 in 2026; 24,570,000 in 2027; 25,061,400 in 2028; 26,781,300 in 2029
Open the Benefit-Cost and Life-Cycle Cost tool (loaded with this example)

Answers

  • Discounted construction costs: 38,500,000 and 15,500,000 / 1.07 = 14,485,981; total 52,985,981 (tool 52,985,981.31)
  • Discounted travel-time savings: 20,387,370; 20,056,439; 19,119,222; 19,094,697; total 78,657,728 (tool 78,657,727.75)
  • Net present value at 7 %: 25,671,746 (tool 25,671,746.44)
  • Benefit-cost ratio (USDOT Section 7) = 78,657,727.75 / 52,985,981.31 = 1.485 (tool; the table prints no ratio)
  • Tool additions: internal rate of return 21.40 %; cumulative discounted net flow turns positive in 2028; NPV 36,306,603 at 3 %; NPV −656,995 with costs 20 % higher and benefits 20 % lower

Notes

The tool's default inputs are this table; press Submit. Every printed cell of Table B-1 is asserted in test_benefit_cost_life_cycle_cost.php, together with the same table of the March 2022 edition (identical amounts, years 2021 to 2026). The tool's second analysis opens with NIST Handbook 135 Example 5-1 (life-cycle cost 643,221.02 and 599,418.45 at full precision; 643,212 and 599,409 as printed with three-decimal factors; SIR 2.61, AIRR 8.06 %, simple payback year 6, discounted payback year 7).