Tools › Mechanical Design › Vehicle Dynamics › Accident Reconstruction › Example
NHTSA CRASH3 Sample Run 1: crush energy, moment arms through the damage centroid and speed change of two cars
| Tool | Accident Reconstruction |
| Source | National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (1986). CRASH3 Technical Manual. Accident Investigation Division, National Center for Statistics and Analysis, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, DC. Sample Run 1 (pages 1.173 to 1.181), Table 1.2 (pages 1.56 and 1.57), equations 2.44, 2.48 and 2.58; moment arms by section 11.3 (pages 11-6 to 11-9) and dimensions from Table 8-1 (page 8-1) of the CRASH3 User's Guide and Technical Manual. |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
A 3,300 lb front-wheel-drive car (CRASH3 stiffness category 9) has frontal damage 70 in wide with six equally spaced crush depths of 15, 12, 10, 7, 3 and 2 in (left to right), struck by a force from the clock direction −40°. The 2,560 lb car it hit (side stiffness category 2) has damage 95 in wide on its right side, depths 0, 5, 10, 7, 5 and 3 in (rear to front), midpoint 16.75 in ahead of its center of mass, force from +50°. Find the crush energy of each car, the moment arm of the force on each, and the speed change of each.
Inputs to Enter
- Analysis: Crush energy (CRASH3). This vehicle: stiffness CRASH3 front, 9 front-wheel drive (A = 373 lb/in, B = 38 lb/in², G = 1,849 lb); six depths 15, 12, 10, 7, 3, 2 in across 70 in on the front; force direction −40°; weight 3,300 lb
- Moment arm: computed from the damage; size category 4 (center of mass to front 98.8 in), damage offset 0, radius of gyration 61.2 in
- Other vehicle: damage entered; weight 2,560 lb; stiffness CRASH3 side, 2 subcompact (A = 140 lb/in, B = 67 lb/in², G = 148 lb); depths 0, 5, 10, 7, 5, 3 in across 95 in on the right side; force direction 50°; size category 2 (center of mass to side 33.6 in), damage offset 16.75 in, radius of gyration 54.3 in
- Ranges: lengths ± 2 %, angles ± 3°, stiffness ± 10 %
Answers
- Equation 2.48: E_0 = (70/5) [373/2 · 81 + 38/6 · 1,230 + 5 · 1,849] = 449,981 in-lb = 37,498 ft-lb
- Force 40° from the perpendicular to the front: factor 1 + tan² 40° = 1.7041; E = 63,901 ft-lb (manual prints 63,792.5 ft-lb, 0.17 % lower)
- Other vehicle: 17,691 ft-lb · 1.7041 = 30,147 ft-lb (manual 30,100.4 ft-lb)
- Damage centroids: (93.74, −10.05) in and (17.92, 30.23) in from the centers of mass; moment arms 52.55 in and 5.70 in; γ = 0.5756 and 0.9891
- Speed changes by equations 2.44 and 2.45: 16.7 mph and 21.6 mph (the manual's printed values)
- From the ranges: energy 50,869 to 80,169 ft-lb, moment arm 48.16 to 56.79 in, speed change of vehicle 1 15.2 to 18.4 mph
Notes
Choose the analysis Crush energy (CRASH3): its opening entries are this case; press Submit. The manual's energies are reproduced to 0.17 %, not to the printed digits (cause not traced); the speed changes agree with the print. The manual prints D′ −10.1 and 17.9 in for the damage centroid offsets, which the tool reproduces. The low and high values are the tool's and are not in the manual.