Tools › Mechanical Design › Vehicle Dynamics › Accident Reconstruction › Example

NHTSA CRASH3 Sample Run 1: crush energy, moment arms through the damage centroid and speed change of two cars

ToolAccident Reconstruction
SourceNational Highway Traffic Safety Administration (1986). CRASH3 Technical Manual. Accident Investigation Division, National Center for Statistics and Analysis, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, DC. Sample Run 1 (pages 1.173 to 1.181), Table 1.2 (pages 1.56 and 1.57), equations 2.44, 2.48 and 2.58; moment arms by section 11.3 (pages 11-6 to 11-9) and dimensions from Table 8-1 (page 8-1) of the CRASH3 User's Guide and Technical Manual.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A 3,300 lb front-wheel-drive car (CRASH3 stiffness category 9) has frontal damage 70 in wide with six equally spaced crush depths of 15, 12, 10, 7, 3 and 2 in (left to right), struck by a force from the clock direction −40°. The 2,560 lb car it hit (side stiffness category 2) has damage 95 in wide on its right side, depths 0, 5, 10, 7, 5 and 3 in (rear to front), midpoint 16.75 in ahead of its center of mass, force from +50°. Find the crush energy of each car, the moment arm of the force on each, and the speed change of each.

Inputs to Enter

  • Analysis: Crush energy (CRASH3). This vehicle: stiffness CRASH3 front, 9 front-wheel drive (A = 373 lb/in, B = 38 lb/in², G = 1,849 lb); six depths 15, 12, 10, 7, 3, 2 in across 70 in on the front; force direction −40°; weight 3,300 lb
  • Moment arm: computed from the damage; size category 4 (center of mass to front 98.8 in), damage offset 0, radius of gyration 61.2 in
  • Other vehicle: damage entered; weight 2,560 lb; stiffness CRASH3 side, 2 subcompact (A = 140 lb/in, B = 67 lb/in², G = 148 lb); depths 0, 5, 10, 7, 5, 3 in across 95 in on the right side; force direction 50°; size category 2 (center of mass to side 33.6 in), damage offset 16.75 in, radius of gyration 54.3 in
  • Ranges: lengths ± 2 %, angles ± 3°, stiffness ± 10 %
Open the Accident Reconstruction tool

Answers

  • Equation 2.48: E_0 = (70/5) [373/2 · 81 + 38/6 · 1,230 + 5 · 1,849] = 449,981 in-lb = 37,498 ft-lb
  • Force 40° from the perpendicular to the front: factor 1 + tan² 40° = 1.7041; E = 63,901 ft-lb (manual prints 63,792.5 ft-lb, 0.17 % lower)
  • Other vehicle: 17,691 ft-lb · 1.7041 = 30,147 ft-lb (manual 30,100.4 ft-lb)
  • Damage centroids: (93.74, −10.05) in and (17.92, 30.23) in from the centers of mass; moment arms 52.55 in and 5.70 in; γ = 0.5756 and 0.9891
  • Speed changes by equations 2.44 and 2.45: 16.7 mph and 21.6 mph (the manual's printed values)
  • From the ranges: energy 50,869 to 80,169 ft-lb, moment arm 48.16 to 56.79 in, speed change of vehicle 1 15.2 to 18.4 mph

Notes

Choose the analysis Crush energy (CRASH3): its opening entries are this case; press Submit. The manual's energies are reproduced to 0.17 %, not to the printed digits (cause not traced); the speed changes agree with the print. The manual prints D′ −10.1 and 17.9 in for the damage centroid offsets, which the tool reproduces. The low and high values are the tool's and are not in the manual.