Tools › Building Systems › Lighting and Electrical › Protective Device Coordination › Example

Four devices in series: IEEE very inverse relay times, intervals and a flagged range on one time-current chart

ToolProtective Device Coordination
SourceInstitute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (1996). IEEE Standard Inverse-Time Characteristic Equations for Overcurrent Relays. IEEE Std C37.112-1996, New York. Equation (2) and Table 1 (very inverse A = 19.61, B = 0.491, p = 2), pp. 3–4; International Electrotechnical Commission (2009). Measuring Relays and Protection Equipment, Part 151. IEC 60255-151:2009, Geneva. Clause 4.4.1.3 (upper limit of the inverse curve, at least 20 times the setting), pp. 11–12; U.S. Department of the Army (1991). Coordinated Power System Protection. Technical Manual TM 5-811-14, Washington, DC. Paragraph 4-2c(1) (common voltage base) and 4-2d(2) (interval 0.3 to 0.4 s), p. 4-2.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A 12.47 kV substation relay (pickup 600 A, time dial 2) backs up a feeder relay (pickup 300 A, time dial 0.8), both IEEE very inverse. The feeder supplies a 1,000 kVA transformer through a primary fuse entered as points, and a 480 V main breaker trip unit (long-time pickup 1,600 A, 4 s at six times pickup, short-time 4,800 A at 0.1 s) is on the secondary. Find the relay operating times for an 8,000 A fault on the 12.47 kV bus, the interval between each adjacent pair against 0.4 s, and any range of current where the interval is lost. The settings and the fuse points are illustrative, not a manufacturer's curve or a published study.

Inputs to Enter

  • Reference voltage 12.47 kV, required interval 0.4 s
  • Device 1 Substation relay: IEEE very inverse, 12.47 kV, pickup 600 A, time dial 2; device 2 Feeder relay: IEEE very inverse, 12.47 kV, pickup 300 A, time dial 0.8
  • Device 3 Transformer fuse: point table at 12.47 kV, (A, melting s, clearing s) = (160, 300, 400), (200, 60, 85), (300, 10, 15), (500, 1.5, 2.4), (1000, 0.2, 0.34), (2000, 0.05, 0.09), (5000, 0.012, 0.025), (8000, 0.01, 0.02)
  • Device 4 LV main breaker: trip unit at 0.48 kV, long-time pickup 1,600 A, 4 s at 6 × pickup, short-time 4,800 A, 0.1 s
  • Faults on the 12.47 kV base: 8,000 A below device 2; 6,000 A below device 3; 900 A (23,381 A at 480 V) below device 4
Open the Protective Device Coordination tool (loaded with this example)

Answers

  • Substation relay at 8,000 A: M = 13.33, t = 2 (19.61 / (13.33² − 1) + 0.491) = 1.20 s
  • Feeder relay at 8,000 A: M = 26.67 is above the 20-multiple limit of the inverse curve, so the time is held at t = 0.8 (19.61 / (20² − 1) + 0.491) = 0.432 s (0.415 s if the equation ran on); interval 0.772 s, meets 0.4 s
  • Feeder relay over fuse at 6,000 A: 0.432 s less the fuse's total clearing 0.023 s (log-log between the entered points) = 0.409 s, meets 0.4 s
  • Breaker long-time pickup on the 12.47 kV base: 1,600 × 0.48 / 12.47 = 61.59 A; at the 480 V fault it trips on short time in 0.100 s
  • Fuse over breaker at 900 A: minimum melting 0.272 s less 0.100 s = 0.172 s, below 0.4 s; the interval is below 0.4 s from 729.6 A to 900 A on the 12.47 kV base (one flagged range, no crossing)

Notes

The tool's default inputs are this case; press Submit. The relay times are hand arithmetic with the equation and constants of IEEE Std C37.112-1996 and the 20-multiple limit of IEC 60255-151:2009; the range boundary is the tool's own numerical result, checked in test_protective_coordination.php against a brute-force search written separately in numpy. No published relay-setting example with printed operating times was found for this tool.