Tools › Aerodynamics › Aircraft Certification › Aircraft Electrical Load Analysis › Method

Aircraft Electrical Load Analysis: Method

Open the Aircraft Electrical Load Analysis tool

Aircraft Electrical Load Analysis: Method, Sources, Assumptions and Limits

What the tool does

When equipment that consumes electrical power is installed in an aircraft, FAA Advisory Circular AC 43.13-1B (paragraph 11-30) asks that the total electrical load be shown to stay within the rated limits of the power supply system, by an electrical load analysis. The airworthiness rules ask the same of the type design: 14 CFR 25.1351(a) and 29.1351(a) require the generating capacity to be determined by an electrical load analysis, and 27.1351(a) and the former 23.1351(a) accept an analysis or measurements "in probable combinations and for probable durations". The established form of such an analysis is the military specification MIL-E-7016F, "Electric Load and Power Source Capacity, Aircraft, Analysis of" (20 July 1976, approved for use by all Departments and Agencies of the Department of Defense, superseding MIL-E-007016E(AS) and MIL-E-7016D(ASG)). This page does the direct-current analysis in that specification's form and terms and prints its charts: the connected load chart, the load analysis chart, the power source utilization analysis with the growth capacity, a utilization graph and the battery analysis. It adds the comparison with the 80 percent figure of AC 43.13-1B, a before-and-after view of a modification, and (Advanced mode) a check of one wire run by section 5 of chapter 11 of the AC.

Operating conditions

MIL-E-7016F (3.5.3.2, 3.5.4.2) lists the operating conditions G1 to G10 as ground maintenance, calibration, loading and preparation, start and warm-up, taxi, takeoff and climb, cruise, cruise-combat, landing and emergency, to be reported in the order of a typical operation of the particular aircraft, with further columns for special conditions. The page carries six conditions and the emergency condition. Their default names are the specification's conditions that apply to a civil airplane: loading and preparation, start and warm-up, taxi, takeoff and climb, cruise, landing. The names are editable in Advanced mode (rename one for loiter, hover or another special condition); a blank name leaves the condition out. Emergency is, in the specification's words, any period of flight during which the normal sources of power are inoperative; the loads essential to safety of flight are listed in the emergency column and analyzed against the alternate source, here the battery.

Loading and preparation is the condition between securing and starting, supplied by an auxiliary power unit, the batteries or external power. By default the page takes condition 1 as supplied by the battery: it is left out of the generator charts and its operating time on the battery is computed. An Advanced select puts it on the generators like the others.

Connected load chart

Each row is one item of equipment, with the columns of the specification's chart (3.5.4.1, Figure 10): functional category code letter (optional), load equipment, total number of units, amperes per unit at nominal system voltage (the average current over the operating time; a load may be entered in watts and is converted by I = P / V), and load operating time, the minutes for which the item draws power in an operating condition. Periods longer than 5 minutes are continuous and are entered as C; a time of 0.005 minute or less counts as 0 (3.5.4.1.6). The page adds three columns of its own: the bus, the status (existing, added or removed by the modification) and an entry for each operating condition: 1 if the load operates, 0 if not, or a fraction for a load running at a lower level.

Load analysis chart

Three analyses are made for each operating condition (3.5.4.2.15): the 5-second analysis enters all loads that last longer than 0.005 minute, the 5-minute analysis all loads that last longer than five seconds, the continuous analysis all loads that last longer than five minutes. The entry of each load is its average amperes (3.5.4.2.14):

average amperes = number of units × amperes per unit × operating time / time interval   where the operating time is less than the interval,

average amperes = number of units × amperes per unit   otherwise and in the continuous analysis.

The chart lists every item under its bus with the 5 s, 5 min and continuous entries of each condition, the bus totals and the system total (the DC load summation of 3.5.4.2.17), as the specification's Figure 11 does.

Power source utilization analysis

The source capacity is developed as in 3.5.4.4 and 6.2.5. The nominal rating of a unit is its nameplate (continuous) rating; its interval ratings are its maximum outputs for 5 minutes and for 5 seconds (entered from the unit specification; the nominal rating is used where none is entered). The source interval rating is the unit rating times the number of units operating in parallel. A rating factor multiplied by the rating gives the capacity under the operating condition: the specification names mechanical (drive torque), electromagnetic (speed) and thermal (cooling) rating factors and a rating factor for paralleling, whose standard value is 0.9 whenever sources operate in parallel unless better load division is demonstrated (3.5.4.4.3d). The composite rating factor is their product and

adjusted source capacity J = composite rating factor × source interval rating.

Growth capacity, the measure of capacity left for future equipment (6.2.6, 6.3.4.1), is

growth capacity = (J − L) × 100 / J   percent, with L the load requirement of the same analysis.

The page prints, for each condition and each of the three analyses, the source interval rating, the adjusted source capacity, the load requirement and the growth capacity, in the row order of the specification's Figure 12, and then the summary the specification asks for (3.5.8.1): the minimum growth capacity of each analysis and the condition that creates it. The specification leaves the required growth capacity to the aircraft detail specification.

The 80 percent figure of AC 43.13-1B. The continuous load is also compared with a limit of 80 percent of the adjusted continuous capacity, which is the same as asking for a continuous growth capacity of 20 percent. The figure is the AC's, in two places. Paragraph 11-35a: when load calculations show that the total continuous electrical load can exceed 80 percent output load limits of the generator or alternator, and where special placards or monitoring devices are not installed, the electrical load must be reduced or the generating capacity of the charging system must be increased. Paragraph 11-35e: where placards or monitoring devices are not practical or desired, and where assurance is needed that the battery will be charged in flight, the total continuous connected electrical load should be held to approximately 80 percent of the total generator output capacity. The AC itself calls this a rule of thumb that should not be confused with an electrical load analysis. The limit is an input (Advanced), so that an installation with an ammeter redlined at 100 percent of the rating (paragraph 11-35d) can be checked against 100.

With two or more units the page also lists the continuous load against the adjusted capacity of the units remaining after one fails, and the load to shed where the load is larger: the load reduction that AC 43.13-1B paragraph 11-35f asks to be identified.

Battery analysis

MIL-E-7016F 3.5.5.1 asks for battery analyses of the loading and preparation condition and of the emergency condition, and sets one number: the initial state of charge assumed shall not exceed 80 percent of nominal capacity. Capacity available = number of batteries × nominal ampere-hours × initial state of charge (0.8 by default) × an entered temperature and age factor.

Loading and preparation (3.5.5.1.1, Figure 15): operating time = (capacity available − ampere-hours kept for engine starting) / continuous load of the condition. The specification's sample is 22.0 − 2.05 = 19.95 Ah over 30 A = 0.66 hour.

Emergency (3.5.5.1.2): the analysis determines the time during which electrical power will be available. The specification gives no formula for it. The page takes the continuous emergency load from the load analysis chart, counts the short-time emergency loads as ampere-hours (amperes × operating time), and lets the battery first carry the whole continuous load of the condition in which the failure happens for an entered time before load shedding:

time = tshed + 60 × (available Ah − Ibefore tshed / 60 − Σ I top / 60) / Iemergency   (minutes)

The time is compared with an entered required duration, and the ampere-hours needed for that duration are printed. The duration is set by the certification and operating basis of the aircraft. The rules read for this page: the former 14 CFR 23.1353(h), in force through Amendment 23-62, required the battery to supply the loads essential to continued safe flight and landing for at least 30 minutes (airplanes certificated to 25,000 ft or less) or 60 minutes (above 25,000 ft), the period including the time to recognize the loss of generated power and to shed load; the current 23.2525(c) asks for enough capacity for the time needed and states no figure; 25.1351(d) and 29.1351(d)(1) require safe operation in VFR conditions for not less than five minutes with normal electrical power inoperative; 135.163(f)(2) accepts, for single-engine aircraft carrying passengers under IFR, a standby battery able to supply 150 percent of the loads of the required instruments and equipment for at least one hour (the emergency multiplier input gives the 150 percent). AC 43.13-1B gives no battery duration. The default five minutes before shedding is an illustrative entered value; no document read for this page gives a figure.

Where the page follows the specification and where it does not

From MIL-E-7016F: the operating-condition names, the connected load chart columns, the operating-time rules, the three analyses and their average-load formula, the load summation by bus and system, the rating terms (nominal rating, interval rating, source interval rating, rating factors, paralleling factor 0.9, composite rating factor, adjusted source capacity), the growth capacity formula, the minimum-growth summary, the 80 percent initial state of charge and the loading-and-preparation battery time.

The page's own constructions: the entry of 0 to 1 per operating condition (the specification's chart simply carries the load or zero, with multiple entries for equipment that operates at several power levels); one entered rating factor per condition standing for the product of the mechanical, electromagnetic and thermal factors, applied to all three analyses (the specification takes the thermal factor as 1.0 in the 5-second analysis; with a factor below 1 the page's 5-second capacity is therefore on the low side); the existing / added / removed status and the before-and-after results; the emergency battery formula above, with its time before load shedding, emergency multiplier and temperature and age factor; the one-generator-out table.

A difference inside the specification. The text of 3.5.4.2.15 enters in the continuous analysis only the loads that last longer than five minutes, and the page follows the text. The sample chart of Figure 11 nevertheless prints entries in its continuous column for short loads (for example 1.55 A for a 4.65 A item, 4.65 × 5 / 15), so its continuous totals are higher than the text gives (9.05 A against 7.5 A in its columns G-2 and G-3). If your authority expects short loads to be averaged into the continuous column, enter them as separate continuous items at their average value.

Not covered

The page is not a complete MIL-E-7016F report. Not built: alternating-current analyses (watts, vars, volt-amperes per phase, phase power factor and phase unbalance, 3.5.4.2.16 and 6.3.1); transient analyses and the peak demand factor for motor starting (3.5.4.3, 6.3.6); fault clearing capacity (3.5.4.7); the battery charging current from the charging-factor graph (6.3.2, Figure 20: enter the charging current as a load item); the inverter input current formula and its efficiency table (6.3.3: enter the inverter's input amperes as a load item); secondary sources and their growth capacity (6.2.6.2); engine starting requirements and starting power source data and the system peak during a start (3.5.6); the ground power analysis (3.5.7); the ground maintenance, calibration, cruise-combat and mission completion conditions as separate columns (rename a condition to use one); separate mechanical, electromagnetic and thermal rating factors and the source capacity curves (3.5.4.4.3, 3.5.4.6); other time intervals (3.5.4.2.15.1); multiple entries for one equipment (3.5.4.4.5.1); the bus wiring diagram, generator mounting and drive data, power source output data, title page, table of contents, notes pages and the report format (3.3, 3.5.1 to 3.5.3). More than one electric system or bus-tie configuration needs a separate run of the page.

Wire run (Advanced)

The wire check follows AC 43.13-1B chapter 11, sections 4 and 5. The tables built into the page are the AC's: Table 11-9 (copper wire, sizes 24 to 0000: continuous-duty current in bundles at 105, 150 and 200 °C conductor ratings, and maximum resistance per 1,000 ft at 20 °C of tin-plated conductor), Table 11-10 (aluminum wire, sizes 8 to 0000, 105 and 150 °C), Table 11-6 (allowable voltage drop between the bus and the utilization equipment ground: 0.5, 1, 4 and 7 volts continuous and twice that intermittent for 14, 28, 115 and 200 volt systems) and Table 11-3 (circuit breaker and fuse for copper wire sizes 22 to 0). Every cell is compared by the test script with the text of the AC.

Voltage drop = resistance per foot × run length × current (the AC's check calculation of Tables 11-7 and 11-8). The run length includes the ground wire where there is one; the return through the structure is taken as negligible (paragraph 11-66c).

Conductor temperature (paragraph 11-66d(6)): T2 = T1 + (TR − T1) √(I / Imax), with T1 the ambient temperature, TR the conductor temperature rating and Imax the maximum allowable current at TR. Above 20 °C the longest run for the allowable drop is shortened (paragraph 11-66d(4)): L2 = 254.5 L1 / (234.5 + T2) for copper and 258.1 L1 / (238.1 + T2) for aluminum, which is the same as multiplying the 20 °C resistance by (234.5 + T2) / 254.5. The page applies that factor to the voltage drop. All wire temperatures are in degrees Celsius in both unit systems, as the AC writes them.

Imax comes from one of three places. The AC's curves (the default; paragraph 11-69): the current of a single copper wire in free air for the temperature difference TR − T1 from Figure 11-4a (sizes 24 to 10) or Figure 11-4b (sizes 8 to 0000), times the bundle derating factor of Figure 11-5 for the number of wires in the bundle and the percent of bundle loading, times the altitude derating factor of Figure 11-6. Table: the tabulated bundle rating of Table 11-9 or 11-10, which the table's note gives for 70 °C ambient, 33 or more wires in the bundle for sizes 24 to 10 and 9 wires for size 8 and larger, no more than 20 percent of harness capacity used, at 60,000 ft. Entered: your own readings of the three figures.

The curves are digitized. The four figures are raster images in the AC; they were traced by a script and calibrated on their own grid lines, and every value that the AC's worked examples read from them was compared with the trace. Reading accuracy: free-air current about ±2 percent (the five printed readings of Figure 11-4a, 47, 21.5, 16.2, 68 and 61 A, are reproduced within 0.7 percent; no example of the AC reads Figure 11-4b, sizes 8 and larger, so that figure is checked only by its grid calibration); bundle derating factor about ±0.01 (printed 0.60, 0.52, 0.43 against 0.599, 0.526, 0.423), about ±0.015 at 2 wires, where the curves leave the corner together, and between 27 and 30 wires, where the legend's leader lines cross the curves; altitude derating factor about ±0.003 (printed 1.0, 0.91, 0.79 against 0.999, 0.908, 0.792). Between the five printed bundle curves (20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 percent) the factor is interpolated linearly; a loading of 20 percent or less uses the 20 percent curve, as the AC does in paragraph 11-69a. The free-air lines are straight on the figures' logarithmic grid and are interpolated on logarithmic scales.

Printed ranges: temperature difference 30 to 250 °C, 1 to 41 wires, 20 to 100 percent loading, sea level to 100,000 ft, copper wire. Outside a range the page gives a message and no value; use the tabulated rating or your own entered values there. For aluminum wire the figures do not apply.

The circuit protector line gives the Table 11-3 values for the wire size and compares an entered breaker rating with the chart value and with the circuit current. The comparison with the circuit current is a plain consistency check added by the page (a breaker rated below the load trips); the AC's rule is paragraph 11-48: the breaker must open before the current rating of the wire is exceeded.

A second table lists every size of the wire table for the same run with the same source of Imax as the check above it (the curves with the same bundle, loading and altitude; the tabulated ratings; or the entered factors applied to each size's free-air current from the figures), and names the smallest size that meets both the allowable drop and the allowable current.

What it assumes

A direct-current system with one set of generators feeding all buses; loads at their entered average currents; every load of a condition that can operate taken as operating in the same interval (the 5-second and 5-minute loads add the short-time loads together); a battery of constant ampere-hour capacity at the entered state of charge and factor; short-time loads ignored during the period before load shedding; wire resistance from the AC's maximum values for tin-plated conductor; a negligible structural return path.

When it misleads

The 80 percent comparison is the AC's rule of thumb for installations without placards or monitoring, not a certification limit. The analysis leaves out starting transients and inrush currents, which the specification treats separately, and everything listed under "Not covered". Most civil alternators have no published 5-minute and 5-second overload ratings; with the nominal rating in their place a short-time load above the capacity shows as a negative growth capacity although the battery carries it in service. A battery delivers fewer ampere-hours at a high discharge rate, at low temperature and when aged; the times printed are only as good as the entered state of charge and factor. The conductor-temperature formula is described by the AC as quite conservative. The derating curves are read from printed charts to the accuracy stated above, and the bundle loading percent is the user's estimate of how much of the bundle's capacity is used. With the tabulated rating as Imax the ratings hold for 70 °C ambient and 60,000 ft; at another ambient the temperature estimate is approximate. The default load list is an illustration made for the page, with currents that are not those of any particular equipment; use the equipment makers' data.

Notes on the source

Three misprints in AC 43.13-1B CHG 1 were found while checking the page against it. Table 11-7, third row, prints the product (.00202)(88)(20) as 3.60; it is 3.56. Table 11-8, second row, prints (.00126)(19.5)(20) as .366; it is 0.491. In Example No. 2 of paragraph 11-68, the second pass (No. 12 wire) evaluates the temperature formula without the square root (20 A / 37 A written as .540, giving 131 °C and 16.7 ft), although the closing sentence states 15.4 feet, which is the result with the square root (160 °C). The same example cites Figure 11-5 for the altitude factor and Figure 11-6 for the bundle factor; the figure titles are the other way round. The page follows the printed formula of paragraph 11-66d(6), with the square root. The same second pass states 37 A as the maximum current of the No. 12 wire at 50 °C ambient; the curves give 62.8 × 0.599 × 0.908 = 34.1 A at the 150 °C difference, and 37 A is 68 × 0.6 × 0.91, the free-air reading at a 175 °C difference (25 °C ambient) of paragraph 11-69b. The page's default run therefore gives 15.8 ft where the AC's closing sentence gives 15.4 ft; the conclusion (No. 14 too small, No. 12 adequate for 15.5 ft) is the same.

In MIL-E-7016F, three growth capacities printed in the sample chart of Figure 12 do not follow from the load and capacity printed above them (78.9 for 82.5 A of 360 A, 52.0 for 139.4 A of 270 A, 23.4 for 137.4 A of 180 A); the other 27 agree with (J − L) × 100 / J within the chart's truncation. The Figure 15 battery sample uses the full 22.0 Ah although 3.5.5.1 limits the assumed state of charge to 80 percent. The copy read is a scan; its text was checked against page images. ASTM F2490 is a copyrighted industry guide, cited only and not read.

Limits

Up to 40 items, six operating conditions and the emergency condition, up to 12 generators and 12 batteries, one wire run.

Checks

The test script reproduces from MIL-E-7016F the average-load rules of 3.5.4.2.14 and 3.5.4.2.15, the unit products and the 12.15 A column totals of Figure 11, the adjusted capacities (360, 270, 180 A) and 27 of the 30 growth capacities of Figure 12, and the battery sample of Figure 15 (2.05 Ah, 19.95 Ah, 0.66 hour). From AC 43.13-1B it compares every cell of Tables 11-3, 11-6, 11-9 and 11-10 with the text of the AC and reproduces the check calculations of Tables 11-7 and 11-8, Examples No. 1 and No. 2 of paragraph 11-68 (182 °C, 9.5 ft, 15.4 ft) and the derated currents of paragraph 11-69 (6.6, 8.8, 29.2 and 23.8 A), both from the printed factors and through the digitized Figures 11-4a, 11-5 and 11-6, whose eleven printed readings are asserted one by one. Thirty seeded load analyses and 60 seeded wire runs are compared with an independent numpy computation. Neither document prints a complete direct-current analysis from connected loads to growth capacity, so the page's default case is checked by hand arithmetic and by that independent computation. This page is a drafting aid, not approved data.