Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Example

Elliptical fuselage frame 96 × 76 in under floor loads reacted by skin shear flow: internal loads by summation and doublers for the added load

ToolRing Frame Analysis
SourceIllustrative case. Method of Niles, A. S., and Newell, J. S. (1943). Airplane Structures, 3rd ed., Vol. I. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Art. 17:7 and p. 276 (eq. 17:21, 17:22 and 17:25 by finite segments for a ring that is not circular); skin shear flow by elementary beam theory, q = VQ/I.
LevelProfessional

Problem

A fuselage frame is shear-tied to a skin whose inner contour is an ellipse with semi-axes 48 in (horizontal) and 38 in (vertical); the frame's centroid lies 2 in inside its outer cap. Four floor loads of 900, 1,300, 1,000 and 700 lb act downward on its lower half at x = −25, −8, 12 and 28 in and are reacted by the shear flow in the skin. The closed-form ring coefficients apply only to a circle, so the frame is solved by finite-segment summation with the VQ/I shear flow of the elliptical skin line. The loads are added loads on an existing frame: check the default cap and web doublers over the whole ring with limit loads entered.

Inputs to Enter

  • Advanced mode; Skin Contour: ellipse, Skin Inner Radius R_s = 48 in (horizontal), Vertical Semi-Axis 38 in; Frame Attachment: shear-tied; Frame Area 0.60 in², Frame Inertia 2.0 in⁴, Centroid to Outer Frame 2 in, Frame Modulus 10.5 Msi
  • Frame Depth 4.5 in, Outer Cap Thickness 0.050 in, Inner Cap Thickness 0.050 in; doublers inside the C
  • Method: finite-segment summation
  • Loads located by x on the lower half: Track 1 to Track 4 at x = −25, −8, 12, 28 in, V = −900, −1,300, −1,000, −700 lb
  • Reinforcement: additional load, limit loads, FS 1.5; default doubler region over the whole ring (0.125 × 1.5 in cap doublers inside the C, 0.050 in web doubler), 2024-T3, 5/32 in fasteners at 0.75 in pitch
Open the Ring Frame Analysis tool

Answers

  • Load points at 231°, 257.53°, 288.69° and 313.81°; resultant 3,900 lb downward with 1,300 lb-in about the center; the balancing shear flow peaks at 33.96 lb/in at the sides
  • Largest moment 18,915 lb-in under Track 2 (257.53°), largest normal force 1,615.7 lb at 225°, largest shear 1,308.2 lb at Track 1 (231°)
  • Moment at 0°, 90°, 180° and 270°: −14,644, 11,365, −14,993 and 16,448 lb-in
  • Vertical diameter lengthens 0.8982 in, horizontal diameter shortens 0.6739 in (frame EI alone)
  • Margins: outer cap tension 64.00/45.52 − 1 = +0.41; inner cap compression 39.00/31.83 − 1 = +0.23; web shear buckling 9.971/9.180 − 1 = +0.09 (lowest); cap fastener 595.7/344.3 − 1 = +0.73; frame-to-skin fastener 595.7/50.95 − 1 = +10.69
  • Doubler centroids y_o = 0.1125 in and y_i = 4.388 in from the frame's outer surface, arm 4.275 in. Zero-margin sizes: web doubler 0.04864 in for buckling (0.050 in entered); cap doubler areas 0.1391 and 0.1184 in² (0.1875 in² entered)

Notes

Enter the inputs above and press Submit; the values are asserted by test_ring_frame_analysis_page.php. The internal loads of this exact case are also solved by the independent numpy model References/Ring-Frame/ring_check.py (scenario ellipse_fuselage), which uses the classical VQ/I shear flow and a 2,880-element frame model; moments agree to 0.01 %. The loads and sizes are invented for illustration, and the margins say nothing about the existing frame under its own baseline loads. Published charts for elliptic rings (NACA TN 444) cover only balanced loads without shear flow; see the companion example.

More Examples for This Tool