Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Example

Doubler over part of a ring frame: how the added stiffness draws bending moment to the reinforced arc (finite-segment summation)

ToolRing Frame Analysis
SourceNiles, A. S., and Newell, J. S. (1943). Airplane Structures, 3rd ed., Vol. I. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Art. 17:8 (loads of the Illustrative Example) and p. 276 (eq. 17:21, 17:22 and 17:25 evaluated by finite segments for a ring of varying EI).
LevelProfessional

Problem

The ring of Niles and Newell's Example 17:8 (centroidal radius 40 in, floor and seat loads of 1,020, 1,440, 935 and 675 lb on the lower half) is reinforced from 200° to 340° with 0.125 × 1.5 in cap doublers on both caps and a 0.050 in web doubler. The loads are treated as added loads carried entirely by the doublers. With constant EI the largest moment is 15,463 lb-in. The doublers raise the EI of the reinforced arc, which changes how the ring shares the moment. Re-solve the ring with the reinforced stiffness and compare the loads, the deflections and the margins.

Inputs to Enter

  • Advanced mode; default frame and loads: Skin Inner Radius 42 in; Frame Attachment: shear-tied (outer cap on the skin); Frame Area 0.60 in², Frame Inertia 2.0 in⁴, Centroid to Outer Frame 2 in, Frame Modulus 10.5 Msi, Skin Thickness 0.040 in; Frame Depth 4.5 in, Outer Cap Thickness 0.050 in, Inner Cap Thickness 0.050 in; loads B, C, D, E by x on the lower half
  • Reinforcement: additional load, limit loads; doubler region 200° to 340°, default doublers inside the C (0.125 × 1.5 in caps, 0.050 in web), 10 end fasteners
  • Stiffness of doublers: first 'Loads from the frame EI alone', then 'Re-solve with the reinforced EI in the regions'
Open the Ring Frame Analysis tool

Answers

  • Frame EI alone (Wise coefficients): largest moment 15,463 lb-in at 269.28°; 11,567 lb-in left to the existing frame outside the region (at 0°); diameter changes +0.5547 and −0.5549 in; lowest margin +0.33 (doubler end fasteners)
  • Doubler centroids y_o = 0.050 + 0.125/2 = 0.1125 in and y_i = 4.5 − 0.050 − 0.125/2 = 4.388 in from the frame's outer surface (arm 4.275 in). Reinforced section: frame plus the two cap doublers, I = 3.728 in⁴, so EI × 1.864 from 200° to 340°; the results now come from the finite-segment summation
  • Re-solved: largest moment 18,367 lb-in at 269.28° (19 % higher), largest normal force 1,655.1 lb and shear −1,046.5 lb at 316.99°; moment left outside the region falls to 10,316 lb-in; diameter changes +0.4423 and −0.4603 in
  • Re-solved margins: outer cap tension 64.00/42.20 − 1 = +0.52; inner cap compression 39.00/31.78 − 1 = +0.23 (lowest); web buckling 9.971/7.344 − 1 = +0.36; cap fastener 595.7/275.4 − 1 = +1.16; doubler end fasteners 5,957/4,024 − 1 = +0.48
  • The three conditions of consistent deformation close to round-off (1e-13) on the re-solved ring

Notes

Enter the inputs above and press Submit once with each setting of 'Stiffness of Doublers'; the values of both runs are asserted by test_ring_frame_analysis_page.php, and a ring with EI × 3.5 over the same arc agrees with the independent numpy model References/Ring-Frame/ring_check.py. Sizing the doubler from the constant-EI loads would have understated the load in it by 19 % here: the stiffer arc attracts moment. The reinforced EI counts the cap doublers only, not the web doubler. The 10,316 lb-in left outside the region is not substantiated by this analysis.

More Examples for This Tool