Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Example

Elliptic ring 25 × 14.7 in under four balanced 2,000 lb loads: thrust, shear and moment against Burke's working charts (NACA TN 444)

ToolRing Frame Analysis
SourceBurke, W. F. (1933). Working Charts for the Stress Analysis of Elliptic Rings. NACA Technical Note 444, National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Washington, DC. Illustrative problem, case 1 (chart case A of its Figure 1), pp. 3–4.
LevelGraduate

Problem

An elliptic ring of uniform cross section has semi-axes a = 25 in (vertical) and b = 14.7 in (horizontal). Two loads of 2,000 lb act upward at the points 45° above the minor axis, and each is reacted by 2,000 lb downward at the nearer end of the minor axis (chart case A). The loads balance, so no skin shear flow is needed. Find the thrust and moment at the end of the major axis and the shear and moment at the ends of the minor axis, and compare them with the values Burke reads from his charts.

Inputs to Enter

  • Advanced mode; Skin Contour: ellipse, Skin Inner Radius R_s = 14.7 in (horizontal semi-axis), Vertical Semi-Axis 25 in; Frame Attachment: shear-tied; Centroid to Outer Frame 0.01 in, so the centroidal line is the chart's ellipse to within 0.01 in; frame area, inertia and modulus at their defaults (they do not affect the internal loads)
  • Method: finite-segment summation; reinforcement checks off
  • Loads located by angle: 45° and 135°, V = +2,000 lb each; 0° and 180°, V = −2,000 lb each
Open the Ring Frame Analysis tool

Answers

  • Load points at x = ±12.66 in, y = 12.67 in: Burke's eccentric angle Φ = 30.5° (tan Φ = (b/a) tan 45°)
  • End of the major axis (90°): thrust 98.616 lb, moment 117.13 lb-in (charts: P_0 = 0.0495 × 2,000 = 99 lb, M_0 = 0.002 × 25 × 2,000 = 100 lb-in from a one-digit coefficient)
  • Ends of the minor axis (0° and 180°): shear 98.616 lb, moment −1,473.9 lb-in, thrust 0 on the side beyond the reaction and 2,000 lb on the side toward the loads (Burke: V_d = 99 lb, P_d = 0, M_d = −1,490 lb-in built from the two chart readings)
  • Under each 2,000 lb load the moment is 1,332.2 lb-in; at the far end of the major axis (270°) 990.52 lb-in
  • Balanced loads: the skin shear flow is 0 lb/in; the three conditions of consistent deformation close to round-off

Notes

Enter the inputs above and press Submit; the values are asserted by test_ring_frame_analysis_page.php, and the same case is checked in the library test with the centroid exactly on the ellipse (98.60 lb, −1,474.4 lb-in, 117.1 lb-in). The tool's moment is positive when it sharpens the curvature. Burke's M_d is assembled from chart readings of two significant figures, which accounts for the 1 % difference; his M_0 comes from a single-digit coefficient. An elliptical frame whose loads are reacted by skin shear flow (the usual fuselage case) is not covered by these charts; the tool's result for that case agrees with the independent numpy model References/Ring-Frame/ring_check.py.

More Examples for This Tool