Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Example

Crown frame under an added antenna side load: added moment, shear and normal force, and doublers sized to carry all of it

ToolRing Frame Analysis
SourceIllustrative case built on Niles, A. S., and Newell, J. S. (1943). Airplane Structures, 3rd ed., Vol. I. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Arts. 17:6 to 17:8 (the Wise coefficients, eq. 17:23 to 17:32); interrivet buckling by Gerard, G. (1957). Handbook of Structural Stability, Part V. NACA Technical Note 3785, eq. 10.
LevelProfessional

Problem

An antenna is added to the crown of a fuselage whose frame loads are not available from the manufacturer. Intercostals bring this frame's share of the antenna loads to two points 10° either side of the crown, at the frame's outer cap: a 600 lb side load (300 lb tangential at each point, clockwise), the overturning of that side load acting 8 in above the skin (4,800 lb-in, resisted by ∓329 lb radial at the two points 14.59 in apart) and 400 lb of lift (200 lb outward at each point). The frame is shear-tied to a skin of 42 in inner radius, with its centroid 2 in inside its outer cap. Find the added bending moment, normal force and shear around the frame, and check 0.063 × 1.0 in cap doublers and a 0.040 in web doubler from 40° to 140°, with limit loads entered and the existing frame given no credit.

Inputs to Enter

  • Advanced mode; Skin Inner Radius 42 in; Frame Attachment: shear-tied (outer cap on the skin); Frame Area 0.60 in², Frame Inertia 2.0 in⁴, Centroid to Outer Frame 2 in, Frame Modulus 10.5 Msi, Skin Thickness 0.040 in (ring radius 40 in)
  • Frame Depth 4.5 in, Outer Cap Thickness 0.050 in, Inner Cap Thickness 0.050 in
  • Loads located by angle: Aft RH at 80°, radial −129 lb (200 − 329), tangential 300 lb, offset +2 in; Aft LH at 100°, radial 529 lb (200 + 329), tangential 300 lb, offset +2 in; the other two rows zero
  • Reinforcement: additional load; limit loads, FS 1.5, yield factor 1.15; Outer and Inner Doubler Placement: inside the C
  • Doubler region 40° to 140°: outer and inner cap doublers 0.063 × 1.0 in, web doubler 0.040 in, 4 end fasteners; 2024-T3 defaults; 5/32 in fasteners at 0.75 in pitch, brazier head; web panel 6 in long
Open the Ring Frame Analysis tool

Answers

  • Each tangential load applied 2 in outboard of the centroidal axis adds a 600 lb-in clockwise couple; resultant F_x = 476.62 lb, F_y = 393.92 lb, moment −25,200 lb-in; peak balancing skin shear flow 7.427 lb/in
  • At the section at 0°: M = −1,202.0 lb-in, N = +87.926 lb, S = −10.530 lb; largest added moment 4,472 lb-in at 100°, normal force 349.44 lb at 105°, shear −324.37 lb at 100°
  • Vertical diameter lengthens 0.08394 in, horizontal diameter shortens 0.07867 in
  • Doubler centroids from the frame's outer surface: y_o = t_fo + t/2 = 0.050 + 0.063/2 = 0.0815 in; y_i = H_f − t_fi − t/2 = 4.5 − 0.050 − 0.063/2 = 4.419 in; couple arm h = 4.337 in; interrivet allowable 37.26 ksi; web shear buckling stress 6.250 ksi
  • Margins (added structure against added load): outer cap tension 64.00/34.66 − 1 = +0.85; inner cap compression 37.26/20.90 − 1 = +0.78 (lowest); web buckling 6.250/2.805 − 1 = +1.23; cap fastener 595.7/84.14 − 1 = +6.08; doubler end fasteners 2,383/624.2 − 1 = +2.82
  • Largest doubler end load 416.11 lb (inner cap at 140°), 2 fasteners needed; outside the region the added loads left to the existing frame peak at |M| = 1,907.0 lb-in at 165°

Notes

Enter the inputs above and press Submit; the values are asserted by test_ring_frame_analysis_page.php. The loads are invented for illustration. The margins say nothing about the existing frame under its own baseline loads, and the 1,907 lb-in left outside the doubler region is not substantiated by this analysis: extend the region or show by other means that the existing frame can take it.

More Examples for This Tool