Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Example
Crown frame under an added antenna side load: added moment, shear and normal force, and doublers sized to carry all of it
| Tool | Ring Frame Analysis |
| Source | Illustrative case built on Niles, A. S., and Newell, J. S. (1943). Airplane Structures, 3rd ed., Vol. I. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Arts. 17:6 to 17:8 (the Wise coefficients, eq. 17:23 to 17:32); interrivet buckling by Gerard, G. (1957). Handbook of Structural Stability, Part V. NACA Technical Note 3785, eq. 10. |
| Level | Professional |
Problem
An antenna is added to the crown of a fuselage whose frame loads are not available from the manufacturer. Intercostals bring this frame's share of the antenna loads to two points 10° either side of the crown, at the frame's outer cap: a 600 lb side load (300 lb tangential at each point, clockwise), the overturning of that side load acting 8 in above the skin (4,800 lb-in, resisted by ∓329 lb radial at the two points 14.59 in apart) and 400 lb of lift (200 lb outward at each point). The frame is shear-tied to a skin of 42 in inner radius, with its centroid 2 in inside its outer cap. Find the added bending moment, normal force and shear around the frame, and check 0.063 × 1.0 in cap doublers and a 0.040 in web doubler from 40° to 140°, with limit loads entered and the existing frame given no credit.
Inputs to Enter
- Advanced mode; Skin Inner Radius 42 in; Frame Attachment: shear-tied (outer cap on the skin); Frame Area 0.60 in², Frame Inertia 2.0 in⁴, Centroid to Outer Frame 2 in, Frame Modulus 10.5 Msi, Skin Thickness 0.040 in (ring radius 40 in)
- Frame Depth 4.5 in, Outer Cap Thickness 0.050 in, Inner Cap Thickness 0.050 in
- Loads located by angle: Aft RH at 80°, radial −129 lb (200 − 329), tangential 300 lb, offset +2 in; Aft LH at 100°, radial 529 lb (200 + 329), tangential 300 lb, offset +2 in; the other two rows zero
- Reinforcement: additional load; limit loads, FS 1.5, yield factor 1.15; Outer and Inner Doubler Placement: inside the C
- Doubler region 40° to 140°: outer and inner cap doublers 0.063 × 1.0 in, web doubler 0.040 in, 4 end fasteners; 2024-T3 defaults; 5/32 in fasteners at 0.75 in pitch, brazier head; web panel 6 in long
Answers
- Each tangential load applied 2 in outboard of the centroidal axis adds a 600 lb-in clockwise couple; resultant F_x = 476.62 lb, F_y = 393.92 lb, moment −25,200 lb-in; peak balancing skin shear flow 7.427 lb/in
- At the section at 0°: M = −1,202.0 lb-in, N = +87.926 lb, S = −10.530 lb; largest added moment 4,472 lb-in at 100°, normal force 349.44 lb at 105°, shear −324.37 lb at 100°
- Vertical diameter lengthens 0.08394 in, horizontal diameter shortens 0.07867 in
- Doubler centroids from the frame's outer surface: y_o = t_fo + t/2 = 0.050 + 0.063/2 = 0.0815 in; y_i = H_f − t_fi − t/2 = 4.5 − 0.050 − 0.063/2 = 4.419 in; couple arm h = 4.337 in; interrivet allowable 37.26 ksi; web shear buckling stress 6.250 ksi
- Margins (added structure against added load): outer cap tension 64.00/34.66 − 1 = +0.85; inner cap compression 37.26/20.90 − 1 = +0.78 (lowest); web buckling 6.250/2.805 − 1 = +1.23; cap fastener 595.7/84.14 − 1 = +6.08; doubler end fasteners 2,383/624.2 − 1 = +2.82
- Largest doubler end load 416.11 lb (inner cap at 140°), 2 fasteners needed; outside the region the added loads left to the existing frame peak at |M| = 1,907.0 lb-in at 165°
Notes
Enter the inputs above and press Submit; the values are asserted by test_ring_frame_analysis_page.php. The loads are invented for illustration. The margins say nothing about the existing frame under its own baseline loads, and the 1,907 lb-in left outside the doubler region is not substantiated by this analysis: extend the region or show by other means that the existing frame can take it.
More Examples for This Tool
- Fuselage ring frame under four floor and seat loads: moment, normal force and shear by the Wise coefficients (Niles and Newell Example 17:8)
- Ring pinched by two opposite radial loads: bending moments and changes of diameter against the classical closed forms
- Fuselage frame with a floor beam and two struts under seat-track loads: ring, floor-beam and strut loads by the finite element model
- Doubler over part of a ring frame: how the added stiffness draws bending moment to the reinforced arc (finite-segment summation)
- Elliptic ring 25 × 14.7 in under four balanced 2,000 lb loads: thrust, shear and moment against Burke's working charts (NACA TN 444)
- Elliptical fuselage frame 96 × 76 in under floor loads reacted by skin shear flow: internal loads by summation and doublers for the added load
- Floating frame standing 1 in off the skin: ring radius, shear flow at the skin line, shear clips and doublers under floor loads