Tools › Structures › Frames and Trusses › Ring Frame Analysis › Method
Ring Frame Analysis: Method
Open the Ring Frame Analysis tool
Ring Frame Analysis: Method, Sign Conventions, Assumptions and Limits
What the tool does
A fuselage frame that receives loads from a floor, seats, a galley, a bin, an antenna or an intercostal passes them to the skin as shear flow. The tool finds the bending moment M, the normal force N and the shear S that this produces at every station around the frame, the deflection of the frame, and, when asked, sizes cap doublers, a web doubler and their fasteners.
The common use is a modification of an existing airplane for which the manufacturer's frame loads are not available. The loads added by the modification are entered alone, the tool returns the added internal loads, and the reinforcement is sized to carry all of them (the "additional load" basis below). The same analysis serves the first layout of a new frame (the "total load" basis).
The ring and its reactions
The frame is a thin ring. Each applied load is held in equilibrium by the shear flow in the skin, taken from elementary beam theory with the stringers smeared into the skin: a force is balanced by a shear flow that varies as the first moment of the skin about the axis normal to the force (sinusoidal on a circle, q = P sin θ / (π R) for a radial load P), and a moment about the center by a uniform shear flow (q = T / (2 π R²) on a circle). For an outline that is not a circle the tool computes the same VQ/I and torque flows numerically for the entered outline.
Closed form: the Wise coefficients
Niles and Newell (arts. 17:6 to 17:8) split each load into a symmetric and an anti-symmetric system about the diameter through the section considered, cut the ring there, and find the moment, normal force and shear at the cut from the conditions that the cut faces do not separate, slide or rotate. With α the angle from the section counter-clockwise to the load, the results are the nine coefficients first published by Wise:
Radial load F (eq. 17:23, 17:24, 17:26): M = F R W1, N = F W2, S = F W3, with W1 = [cos α / 2 − (π − α) sin α + 1] / 2π, W2 = [3 cos α / 2 + (π − α) sin α] / 2π, W3 = [(π − α) cos α − sin α / 2] / 2π.
Tangential load F (eq. 17:27 to 17:29): M = F R W4, N = F W5, S = F W6, with W4 = [3 sin α / 2 + (π − α)(cos α − 1)] / 2π, W5 = [sin α / 2 − (π − α) cos α] / 2π, W6 = [(π − α) sin α − 1 − cos α / 2] / 2π.
Couple Mc (eq. 17:30 to 17:32): M = Mc W7, N = Mc W8 / R, S = Mc W9 / R, with W7 = [2 sin α + α − π] / 2π, W8 = −2 sin α / 2π, W9 = −[1 + 2 cos α] / 2π.
The coefficients are influence lines: for any other section the same expressions are used with α measured from that section. Loads are superposed. A load spread over an arc is the integral of the coefficients over the arc, which the tool evaluates numerically. The moment directly under a radial load is 3 F R / (4π) = 0.239 F R.
Sign conventions
These are the book's. Radial loads are positive outward. Tangential loads and couples are positive clockwise, whichever way the angles are chosen to run. V is positive upward and H to the right. The bending moment is positive when it sharpens the curvature of the ring (tension on the outer fiber, compression on the inner). The normal force is positive in tension. The shear is positive when it acts toward the center on the face of the part of the ring lying counter-clockwise of the cut. The book measures angles counter-clockwise from the right-hand horizontal axis; the zero and the direction can be changed, and x and y positions always use x to the right and y up from the ring center.
Centroidal radius, effective skin and the skin-line correction
The ring radius in every expression is the radius to the centroid of the frame section, not the skin radius. The tool takes the Skin Inner Radius, Rs, and the Centroid to Outer Frame distance, yf, measured from the outer surface of the frame's outer cap to the centroid of the frame. A shear-tied frame has its outer cap on the skin, so R = Rs − yf. A floating frame stands off from the skin, tied to it only by shear clips, with the stringers passing through the Gap to Inner Skin, gsk, between its outer cap and the skin: R = Rs − gsk − yf. Every distance in the frame cross-section (centroid, doublers, Frame Depth Hf) is measured inboard from the outer surface of the frame's outer cap. The two figures at the top of the form, one for each Frame Attachment, show these dimensions with the symbols of the inputs; the one that applies is repeated as Figure 1 of the results. With effective skin on (shear-tied frames only: a floating frame has no skin attached along its cap), a strip of skin of thickness tsk is added to the section and the centroid, the inertia and the radius are recomputed; the combined centroid distance, written ȳ in the results, then takes the place of yf. Loading a saved section fills the Frame Area, the Frame Inertia, the Centroid to Outer Frame distance and the Frame Depth for the side of the drawn section chosen as the skin side, and clears the two cap thicknesses, which a saved section does not carry and which must be entered: for the top or bottom of the drawing the inertia is Ixx and the distance is that from the centroid to that fiber; for the right or left it is Iyy and the distance to that side. The product of inertia of an unsymmetrical section is not used.
The book treats the shear flow as acting around the centroidal axis, while noting that it acts at the periphery. The skin-line correction applies the shear flow at the mid-thickness of the skin, which for a floating frame lies the gap gsk further out, and adds to the ring a distributed couple equal to the shear flow times the offset. On a circular ring a couple distributed sinusoidally or uniformly is carried by shear and normal force alone, so the correction changes S and N by about the ratio of the offset to the radius times the shear-flow force, and leaves the bending moment unchanged. This is the case treated by Fahlbusch and Wegner (NACA TM 999), whose equations for a radial force, a moment and a tangential force with the shear flow at a radius R and the neutral fiber at a radius r the tool reproduces: their moment equations do not contain R, while their normal and transverse forces contain the ratio R / r. A tangential load applied off the centroidal axis (their load case D) is entered with the Offset column.
Varying stiffness and other shapes: summation
For a ring whose EI is not constant, or which is not circular, Niles and Newell (p. 276) evaluate the same three conditions by finite segments: Σ (M / EI) Δs = 0, Σ (M x / EI) Δs = 0 and Σ (M y / EI) Δs = 0 around the ring, with M written in terms of the three unknowns at the cut. The tool divides the centroidal line into segments of half a degree, applies the loads and the shear flow at the nodes, and solves the three equations. It reproduces the Wise coefficients for a circular ring of constant EI to within the discretization (about 0.01 %), and the illustrative elliptic ring of Burke's working charts (NACA TN 444) to within the reading of the charts.
Finite element model
A floor beam, struts or a pinned splice make the frame more than a single closed ring. For these the tool builds a plane frame of straight beam elements on the centroidal line and solves it with the solver of the Truss and Frame Analysis tool. The applied loads and the shear flow balance, so the three restraints that fix the model in space carry no load; their reactions are printed as a check. The floor beam is assumed not to change the skin shear flow. The elements stretch as well as bend, so the results differ slightly from the inextensible ring of the other two methods.
Deflections
The change of slope along the ring is M / EI per unit length (eq. 17:19 and 17:20); the tool integrates it around the ring. Because the ring is held only by the shear flow, its position as a whole is arbitrary and a reference has to be chosen: the best-fit rigid-body motion removed (the default, which leaves only the change of shape), a section held fixed in position and slope (the book's reference), or the line through two chosen points. Changes of diameter are the same in all three.
Reinforcement
Additional load. The entered loads are those added to an existing frame. The existing frame is given no credit. At each station the added moment and normal force are resolved into loads in an outer and an inner cap doubler, with the couple arm h equal to the distance between the doubler centroids: Po = N (yi − ȳ) / h + M / h and Pi = N (ȳ − yo) / h − M / h. A bending moment is a couple, so a doubler is required on both caps. The added shear is carried by a web doubler at the shear flow q = |S| / h. The margins are those of the added structure against the added load.
Placement of the cap doublers. The frame is taken as a C section with its outer cap toward the skin. Each cap doubler is placed by a selection, and its centroid distance from the outer surface of the frame's outer cap (yo for the outer doubler, yi for the inner) follows from the Frame Depth Hf, the Outer and Inner Cap Thickness tfo and tfi and the doubler thickness t and width w; the results print each one as formula, numbers and answer. Outer doubler: inside the C on the outer cap, yo = tfo + t / 2 (the default); on the web beside the cap, yo = tfo + w / 2. The outer doubler goes on the frame's outer cap, not on the skin. Inner doubler: inside the C on the inner cap, yi = Hf − tfi − t / 2 (the default); outside the C on the free face, yi = Hf + t / 2; on the web beside the cap, yi = Hf − tfi − w / 2. The couple arm is h = yi − yo. With Custom placement the centroid is entered, which suits an angle or a formed section; such a part is checked in compression with an entered crippling allowable, because interrivet buckling describes a flat strap between fasteners.
Total load. The entered loads are the complete frame loads. Stresses are those of the frame and its doublers as one section, f = N / A + M′ (ȳc − y) / I, at the frame's outer and inner fibers and at the doubler centroids.
Checks. Cap doublers: tension on the net area against Ftu; compression against interrivet buckling (NACA TN 3785 eq. 10, with the end-fixity coefficient of the fastener head and the tangent-modulus plasticity correction, capped at Fcy) or an entered allowable; yield at limit load. Web: shear strength, shear buckling of the flat panel between stiffeners, with ks = 5.35 + 4 (b/a)² for simply supported edges and 8.98 + 5.6 (b/a)² for clamped edges, b the shorter side (the simply supported formula, for all four edges simply supported, is that of Timoshenko and Gere, 2nd ed., p. 383, and is the one the Plate Buckling tool uses; its long-plate value 5.35 and the clamped long-plate value 8.98 are also those of NACA TN 3781 Table 1; the clamped formula is for all four edges clamped, the coefficient differs when only the long edges are clamped, and that case is not offered), and shear yield with Fsy = (Fty / Ftu) Fsu by default, Fty / √3 or an entered value as alternatives. Fasteners: the load per cap fastener (shear flow into the doubler times the pitch), the fasteners needed to develop each cap doubler where it ends, and the frame-to-skin fasteners or shear clips under the skin shear flow. The fastener allowable is entered, or computed as the lowest of fastener shear and bearing in the added and existing parts.
Load level. Strength, buckling and fastener margins are written at ultimate load and yield margins at limit load times the yield factor; the entered loads are converted according to whether they are limit or ultimate.
Stiffness of the doublers. A doubler over part of the ring stiffens it there and draws moment toward it. The option to re-solve uses the summation method with the EI of the frame plus cap doublers inside each region.
Reading the results
The first line of the results names the method the numbers come from, and every table title and chart caption repeats it. In the comparison mode the results are those of the first method that applies to the ring (the closed form for a circular ring of constant EI without a floor beam, strut or splice; otherwise the summation; otherwise the finite element model), and the other methods appear only as the largest differences in the comparison table. When the internal loads are re-solved with the stiffness of the doublers, they come from the summation method even if the Wise coefficients were selected, and the page says so. In the load table, the cells that do not apply to the chosen way of locating a load are grayed.
What it assumes
A thin ring (section depth small against the radius) with an inextensible centroidal axis and no shear deformation; skin shear flow from elementary beam theory with the stringers smeared; a frame that is rigid in its own plane compared with the shell, so that the whole of each load is reacted at the loaded frame; loads in the plane of the frame only; linear elastic behavior.
When it misleads
A flexible frame in a stiff shell sheds part of a concentrated load to the neighboring frames through the skin and stringers; the method then overstates the bending in the loaded frame and understates it in the neighbors. Near a large cutout (a door or a window belt) the shear flow is not the smooth distribution assumed. A floating frame receives its reactions at discrete shear clips, not continuously. In a deep frame on a small radius the fiber stresses follow curved-beam theory, not M c / I. Forward and aft loads, and the local introduction of each load through its fitting, are outside the analysis. On the additional-load basis the margins say nothing about the existing frame under its baseline loads: the method shows that the added structure can carry what was added, on the assumption that the existing structure has no reserve to lend and none to lose.